The great arguments in recent boxing history

[ripcity]

1. Who won Marvin Hagler or Sugar Ray Leonard?
2. Should Richard Steele have stoped the first Julio Cesar Chavez-Meldrick Taylor fight?
3. Who would have won Lennox Lewis or Riddick Bowe?
4. How should the first round of David Diaz vs. Erik Morales be scored?

My answers
1. I had Leonard wining 115-113
2. Yes I used to think no (flasing light says 10 seconds or less not 2 seconds). Ref's job is to protect the safty of the boxers.
3. At the point in time they should have fought 92-94 I beleve Bowe would have won. Prime for Pime Lewis would Win.
4. I had it 10-8 Morales but I can see the round being 10-9 Morales or 10-9 Diaz.:bbb

[theunderdog]

1. Who won Marvin Hagler or Sugar Ray Leonard?
2. Should Richard Steele have stoped the first Julio Cesar Chavez-Meldrick Taylor fight?
3. Who would have won Lennox Lewis or Riddick Bowe?
4. How should the first round of David Diaz vs. Erik Morales be scored?

My answers
1. I had Leonard wining 115-113
2. Yes I used to think no (flasing light says 10 seconds or less not 2 seconds). Ref's job is to protect the safty of the boxers.
3. At the point in time they should have fought 92-94 I beleve Bowe would have won. Prime for Pime Lewis would Win.
4. I had it 10-8 Morales but I can see the round being 10-9 Morales or 10-9 Diaz.:bbb

how could it be 10-9 diaz? he didn't get penalized for getting knocked down?

[kg0208]

Holyfield vs Lewis (2) was the worst decision EVER in a heavyweight title fight Holyfield was ROBBED

Not a great argument if one side has hardly any support. You and a handful of others would believe this.

[H .]

how could it be 10-9 diaz? he didn't get penalized for getting knocked down?

Yeah, I've never ever heard of that happening before.

[Farmboxer]

I hate all the damned lies about Vitali and Vladimir Klitschko. Vlad is a ring artist and should be watched, he is so very excellent and Vitali is a true warrior who will knock McCline out, then knock out the winner of Maskaev/Peter fight.

[ripcity]

how could it be 10-9 diaz? he didn't get penalized for getting knocked down?
an arugument can be made that Diaz won the round despite the knockdown.

[Rollo]

Yeah, I've never ever heard of that happening before.



Johnny Bredahl was knocked down in his fight agaist Paulie Ayala, but the round was scored 10-10 because Bredahl was totally dominating in that round.

[theunderdog]

I hate all the damned lies about Vitali and Vladimir Klitschko. Vlad is a ring artist and should be watched, he is so very excellent and Vitali is a true warrior who will knock McCline out, then knock out the winner of Maskaev/Peter fight.


???

[Napoleon]

1. Who won Marvin Hagler or Sugar Ray Leonard?
2. Should Richard Steele have stoped the first Julio Cesar Chavez-Meldrick Taylor fight?
3. Who would have won Lennox Lewis or Riddick Bowe?
4. How should the first round of David Diaz vs. Erik Morales be scored?


1. Never seen the fight
2. Fuck No
3. I'd pick Lennox Lewis
4. Will see it later :think

[H .]

Johnny Bredahl was knocked down in his fight agaist Paulie Ayala, but the round was scored 10-10 because Bredahl was totally dominating in that round.

Right, but that's still not 10-9 in favor of the guy knocked down.

[theunderdog]

an arugument can be made that Diaz won the round despite the knockdown.

but it also must be taken into consideration that a round with a kd should be 10-8, so, give it 10-8 to em and give diaz an extra point for winning the round so 10-9 for em. but 10-9 fo diaz? you'd have to look away from the kd to score that a 10-9 round for diaz noob.

[theunderdog]

Right, but that's still not 10-9 in favor of the guy knocked down.

exactly!!! what was the dude thinking? his arguement was not even remotley relevant to what we were discussing:yep

[Vantage_West]

no one has said the lennox lewis vitali klitchsko...that fued has been going on for ages pictures replays everything to prove a point

which both side say there man won or was winning....till a mischifis dreadlock snapped into vitali eye cutting him in 2 sepratre places....fucking ddreads can they have peace and fucking brotherly love with eyes...


anyways i feel THIS is biggest arguement of all time

[My dinner with Conteh]

1. Leonard.
2. Probably not.
3. Lewis.
4. 10-9. (Morales)

[Casa]

You have to deduct a point for the KD, regardless of everything else. I don't see how you could give the round to Diaz.

[Lacyace]

1. Who won Marvin Hagler or Sugar Ray Leonard?
2. Should Richard Steele have stoped the first Julio Cesar Chavez-Meldrick Taylor fight?
3. Who would have won Lennox Lewis or Riddick Bowe?
4. How should the first round of David Diaz vs. Erik Morales be scored?

1. SRL eeked out a close one.
2. Yes. Taylor was technically knocked out before the bell rung.
3. Peak Riddick Bowe would've won.
4. I didn't see it yet.