Best H2H to fighter

[WhataRock]

Regardless of resumes who do you think is the best fighter at these weights today and all time?

As in the fighter who would beat all others in that division, even if he didnt/doesnt have the best record.


Lightheavy...

Middleweight...

Welterweight...

Jnr Welter...

Lightweight...

[WhataRock]

I feel it would be..

Lightheavy...Alltime Bob Foster....Today Joe C.

Middle...Alltime a hard one but if I had to pick one name it would be Monzon...Today give a slight edge to Abraham over Pavlik

Welter...Alltime Has to be Robinson surely...Today Hard one, Margarito could potentially beat everyone (lets assume Williams is not a welter now) but I wouldnt be overly confident of that.

Jnr Welter...Alltime Ill give it to Pryor here...Today I suppose Hatton

Lightweight...Alltime Duran...Today JMM

[Loewe]

I feel it would be..

Lightheavy...Alltime Bob Foster....Today Joe C.

Middle...Alltime a hard one but if I had to pick one name it would be Monzon...Today give a slight edge to Abraham over Pavlik

Welter...Alltime Has to be Robinson surely...Today Hard one, Margarito could potentially beat everyone (lets assume Williams is not a welter now) but I wouldnt be overly confident of that.

Jnr Welter...Alltime Ill give it to Pryor here...Today I suppose Hatton

Lightweight...Alltime Duran...Today JMM

I agree with your picks at lhw, ww and lw but only partly with the other weights.
At mw, Monzon is the best ever h2h I agree but today it´s a bit of a puzzle. The three best mw could all beat each other style wise. Personally, I pick Abraham to beat Pavlik but lose to Sturm and Pavlik to beat Sturm. I hope these fights come off.
Jww is a bit more difficult than just to say Pryor. Imo either Toni Canzoneri any Barney Ross also have a good shot there. I agree with Hatton though.

[DINAMITA]

Regardless of resumes who do you think is the best fighter at these weights today and all time?

As in the fighter who would beat all others in that division, even if he didnt/doesnt have the best record.


Lightheavy...

Middleweight...

Welterweight...

Jnr Welter...

Lightweight...

LIGHTHEAVY: Foster and Hopkins
MIDDLE: Monzon and Abraham
WELTER: Robinson/Leonard and Margarito
JR WELTER: Whitaker and Hatton
LIGHT: Duran and Pacquiao

[SuzieQ49]

Light-Heavyweight- Ezzard Charles

Welterweight- Sugary Ray Robinson

Lightweight- Roberto Duran

[mcvey]

Regardless of resumes who do you think is the best fighter at these weights today and all time?

As in the fighter who would beat all others in that division, even if he didnt/doesnt have the best record.


Lightheavy...

Middleweight...

Welterweight...

Jnr Welter...

Lightweight...
LH LANGFORD [I'll be different]
M GREB
W ROBINSON
L LEONARD

[JohnThomas1]

Light-Heavyweight- Ezzard Charles

Welterweight- Sugary Ray Robinson

Lightweight- Roberto Duran

But, but, but where's today!!!!!!!

:lol:

[ripcity]

Al time present
Lightheavy Roy Jones Jr Chad Dawson
Middleweight Carlos Monzon Kelly Pavlik
Welterweight Ray Leonard Paul Williams
Jnr Welter Aaron Pryor Ricky Hatton
Lightweight Benny Leonard Juan Manuel Marquez