Please rate these fighters 1-12 in all-time pound-for-pound standings...

[DINAMITA]

From 1-12 please gentlemen:

Rocky Graziano
Sumbu Kalambay
Dwight Muhammad Qawi
Panama Al Brown
Kid Chocolate
Nicolino Locche
Donald Curry
Hector Camacho
Jack Dempsey (the heavyweight)
Joe Calzaghe
Shane Mosley
Khaosai Galaxy


All opinions welcome. Cheers

[DINAMITA]

I can´t really rank them in a clear order but only put them in three groups and rank those.

Panama Al Brown
Kid Chocolate
Nicolino Locche
Jack Dempsey (the heavyweight)

Joe Calzaghe
Hector Camacho
Donald Curry
Rocky Graziano

Shane Mosley
Khaosai Galaxy
Dwight Muhammad Qawi
Sumbu Kalambay

I´m not sure with Qwawi and Camacho though.

Thank you for your input Loewe, much appreciated as always.

Do you mind if I ask you why you believe Brown and Chocolate deserve to be ranked higher than Calzaghe or Graziano?

And why are you not sure about Qawi or Camacho?

[the cobra]

I agree with the basic grouping that rukelie has, although I'd probably put Qawi in the group with Calzaghe, Camacho, etc. Maybe Locche would drop to that group also.

[Mantequilla]

I think a lot of these fighters are on a similar level overall, taking head to head worth and accomplishments into play.

Camacho, Graziano and Galaxy are the least impressive to me.

Camacho is the most overrated "coulda shoulda woulda" fighter of the past 40 years at least.a rank amatuer in comparison to some others in that category like Curry, Rose, Gregory and Conteh.

[My2Sense]

Camacho is the most overrated "coulda shoulda woulda" fighter of the past 40 years at least.a rank amatuer in comparison to some others in that category like Curry, Rose, Gregory and Conteh.

Agreed. I give a lot more thought to what Rose and Conteh could've been than to that fragile bitch Camacho.