Who is pound for pound number 1

[The Phenom]

Gsp.He will win a unanimous decison over Penn and nobody can beat him when he is at his best.

[sugarngold]

Fedor. GSP isn't far enough removed from that KO loss to Matt Serra and Anderson Silva still has heel hook nightmares in his closet. Fedor's record is nigh spotless.

[québecwarrior]

Fedor
GSP, A.Silva and Penn are all equal in my opinion.
A.Silva need to go to 205 to fight big name.

[fundador]

no doubt FEDOR is the # 1 lb for lb in MMA

[Cameron]

its fedor with out a question then anderson then miguel torres. like some one said gsp is still not to far off his ko loss. miguel is a terro in his division and on a 16 fight win streak dominating top tens in his last three outings as well his only loss was to a guy who was a wieght division above him. penn in my oppinon needs to just get a mad win streak going he keeps fliping between weight classes and it dose him no good. he needs to stay at 155 and dominate and become a fedor or anderson or torres someone that is untouchable in his own weight instead of chasing dreams in WW.

[ufoalf]

Torres is good but I'm just not sure about the depth of that weight division.

[Dostoevsky]

Not Fedor.

[ufoalf]

Not Fedor.

:lol:

Change your nickname, now!

[québecwarrior]

your avatar is very gay ufoalf, when are we gonna be able to put back the old one lol?

[Boyd]

your avatar is very gay ufoalf, when are we gonna be able to put back the old one lol?i think it's the 15th.

[sugarngold]

your avatar is very gay ufoalf, when are we gonna be able to put back the old one lol?

lol

Not long now. Next weekend we can change back.

[Polymath]

Not Fedor.

Hello Iron Duke :hi:

[ufoalf]

your avatar is very gay ufoalf, when are we gonna be able to put back the old one lol?

Well thanks, sweetheart, your's too :). It's the 15th :P.

[Serenata]

Fedor, who else :D

[Polymath]

I actually agree with Iron Duke tbf, its one of the smaller guys; Penn, GSP, maybe even someone like Faber. A. Silva if youre looking for a bigger guy.

[ufoalf]

I actually agree with Iron Duke tbf, its one of the smaller guys; Penn, GSP, maybe even someone like Faber. A. Silva if youre looking for a bigger guy.


Its not what the majority says :D

[Polymath]

Its not what the majority says :D

Democracy fails again....

[codeman99998]

Fedor is probably more than just #1 p4p. He is probably the GOAT in MMA.

[Cameron]

Torres is good but I'm just not sure about the depth of that weight division.

ill give you that but i also belive he would still fuck shit up at 145 considering he has faught guys who were 170 and still beat them

[ufoalf]

ill give you that but i also belive he would still fuck shit up at 145 considering he has faught guys who were 170 and still beat them


Oooh, Kid vs Torres at 145? That'd be a cool fight. Good contrast of styles too.

Too bad Yamamoto has been out of action for so long.

[Weber]

Fedor is probably more than just #1 p4p. He is probably the GOAT in MMA.

Yeah. The guy has hardly showed a single sign of weakness in 30 fights. He is simply head and shoulders above anyone else.

[Cameron]

Oooh, Kid vs Torres at 145? That'd be a cool fight. Good contrast of styles too.

Too bad Yamamoto has been out of action for so long.


i hear you on that also funny how kid is a natural 135er but hasnt faught there in years. i just wish he would stop trying to be a gangster and just fucking fight

[AJAX]

I actually agree with Iron Duke tbf, its one of the smaller guys; Penn, GSP, maybe even someone like Faber. A. Silva if youre looking for a bigger guy.


Is that the Iron Duke? he dissapeared a while ago. And why does pfp have to be a smaller guy, Fedor has not lost a fight yet, until someone beats him does he is easily #1. Silva is #2 Gsp#3 and B.J #4 and they are the only 4 who are "dominate" in their divisions.

[AJAX]

And give Brock some time I think he can be a dominate champ, He is still green and is only getting better...very quickly.

[sugarngold]

You have to give it to Fedor for beating two guys in their fighting prime with wildly different fighting styles. He dominated Minotauro when Noqueira was submitting everyone and then Fedor battered Crocop after Mirko had been knocking everyone stiff into the mat. Fedor has proven that he can defeat anyone.

[sugarngold]

Is that the Iron Duke? he dissapeared a while ago. And why does pfp have to be a smaller guy, Fedor has not lost a fight yet, until someone beats him does he is easily #1. Silva is #2 Gsp#3 and B.J #4 and they are the only 4 who are "dominate" in their divisions.

Doesn't Iron Duke still float around in the Lounge?

[AJAX]

Not that I know of he was a regular here.....but then dissapeared.

[sugarngold]

Not that I know of he was a regular here.....but then dissapeared.

You're right. Iron Duke hasn't been active since February.

[chimba]

Fedor. GSP isn't far enough removed from that KO loss to Matt Serra and Anderson Silva still has heel hook nightmares in his closet. Fedor's record is nigh spotless.

youre reaching there..Silva had the best comp in the last two years.. I say hes p4p1

[ufoalf]

Fedor is your favorite fighter's favorite fighter.

[rusty nails]

machida..
undefeated, beaten penn, franklin, ortiz etc.. unchallenged at the top now in my opinion

[ufoalf]

machida..
undefeated, beaten penn, franklin, ortiz etc.. unchallenged at the top now in my opinion

Hasn't beaten anyone of note at 205 cept couple of gatekeepers.

[fundador]

machida..
undefeated, beaten penn, franklin, ortiz etc.. unchallenged at the top now in my opinion

do you guys thnk machida is underated?

[The Phenom]

do you guys thnk machida is underated?
Rashad Evans is the next title contender and he only drew with Ortiz.In fairness Tito Ortiz beat Griffin aswell and the fight with Machida was competitive Ortiz is not as shot as Dana White says.Machida is stepping into the division at a good time in my opinion the only one who can stop him is Anderson Silva.

[Cameron]

the silva with will never happen they are team mates

[sugarngold]

youre reaching there..Silva had the best comp in the last two years.. I say hes p4p1

Perhaps you are right - but Fedor's victories over Crocop and Nogueira still place him at the top of the list in my book. He is essentially undefeated aside from that one bogus blemish against TK.

[Weber]

Perhaps you are right - but Fedor's victories over Crocop and Nogueira still place him at the top of the list in my book. He is essentially undefeated aside from that one bogus blemish against TK.

Yeah. Fedor utterly destroyed the guy in their rematch anyway. That "loss" doesn't count for shit in my book.

[berserkafied]

Fedor....Damn I cliked on A. Silva on the poll.

[QuestionKid7]

How can OP put GSP at number 1 pfp over fedor and a. silva? Fedor is defiantly number. GSP beat BJPenn and that is a great win Penn is a top fighter. But he didn't dominate. Even after he beats BJ for a second time he cant be placed over fedor.