Who should retire from boxing?

[Boricua - TLH]

I think Tito should stay out, Jones should do as well. DLH should stick to promote and Mosley should retire after his next two fights. Judah should either go down to 140 or retire. Holyfield should stick to charity events... Any thoughts?

[TBooze]

Holyfield should go, but will not

Calzaghe should call it a day win or lose against Kessler

Hopkins has nothing left to prove

[DamonD]

Riddick Bowe. Of all the current comebacking HWs, he seems to have the least to offer.

[Fedor Em]

Jones, Tito, Castillo, Barrera after Pac, Holyfield, Toney, and Larios.

[heerko koois]

Mayweather.....

[MrMagic]

The names you all mentioned makes me laugh out loud.
Hopkins? Why? he's got enough to beat MOST guys out there.. he just beat Winky ffs.
Mayweather? well, that's just hatred..
Holyfield?... he's getting a title shot, let him fight and then decide.


Fedor Em : Jones, Tito, Castillo, Barrera after Pac, Holyfield, Toney, and Larios.

Every one marked I would agree with, Castillo I don't really know about right now, he still has enough to beat most guys out there, to be honest.

[Caper]

Jason Litz.....

Before he gets hurt.

[KO byBRIGGS]

Mayweather.....
why Mayweather the guy is at his prime he should box for another 5 years and secure his legacy as an atg because he has the skill to do be on of the goat but he would have to continue fighting for some time to prove it.

[heerko koois]

why Mayweather the guy is at his prime he should box for another 5 years and secure his legacy as an atg because he has the skill to do be on of the goat but he would have to continue fighting for some time to prove it.

meant it as a joke.....do you think that he beats Hatton ?

[KO byBRIGGS]

meant it as a joke.....do you think that he beats Hatton ?
I think at 147 Floyd will win a UD or possibly but unlikely late round TKO.

but.....if the fight had taken place at 140 today perhaps that would favour Hatton at this point in time. I am no huge fan of Mayweather but I just dont see Hatton being the man to break Mayweather especially at 147.

[Fedor Em]

These, and Hopkins, Bowe, Sanders, Brewster, Davis, Johnson, Calzaghe after Kessler, DLH, Mosley after Cotto.

Hopkins is still world class no doubt, he needs to fight the winner of Calzaghe/Kessler, if he loses he is still and ATG, if he wins put his name next to Chavez, Hagler, Spinks, and Holyfield on the p4p list cause that is where he deserves to be mentioned. I think if Mosley beats Cotto he should go for the winner of PBF/Hatton too, that is another huge legacy fight. Glen Johnson is still a top contender as well.

[Fedor Em]

The names you all mentioned makes me laugh out loud.
Hopkins? Why? he's got enough to beat MOST guys out there.. he just beat Winky ffs.
Mayweather? well, that's just hatred..
Holyfield?... he's getting a title shot, let him fight and then decide.


Fedor Em : Jones, Tito, Castillo, Barrera after Pac, Holyfield, Toney, and Larios.

Every one marked I would agree with, Castillo I don't really know about right now, he still has enough to beat most guys out there, to be honest.

Yeah Castillo still has some in the tank, but I think Paulie would win a UD over him now, and of course he loses to Hatton again. Witter would be a 50/50 fight as well.

[Brickhaus]

Joe Mesi.

[Stinky gloves]

Riddick Bowe. Of all the current comebacking HWs, he seems to have the least to offer.

:good

[Alo2006]

Holyfield, and Bowe.

[Stinky gloves]

Joe Mesi.

Mesi must still prove how bad is he now.:dead

[jhar26]

Bowe I guess. He's not just a shadow of his former self but a shadow of the shadow of his former self. Holyfield should have retired years ago, but now that he's come this far he might as well have a go even though I don't think he'll have much of a chance.

Guys like Jones and Trinidad are past their prime but they can still put on a good show. No reason for them to retire if they still get a kick out of it. They would be wise to avoid certain fighters though (as in Tito's case, he should avoid Jones, not choose him as an opponent in a comeback fight).

Hopkins, Mayweather and some of those other guys that have been mentionned: No reason whatsoever for them to retire.

[andyZOR]

Holyfield should go, but will not

Calzaghe should call it a day win or lose against Kessler

Hopkins has nothing left to prove
Holy Should go? Dude son, you can't back dwn from a title shot. Hes staying, and he should stay.

[chung]

not winky

[Scar]

Morales
Jones Jr.
Holyfield
Bowe
Mesi
Castillo
Hopkins
DLH
Mosley
Judah

[rodney]

Joe Mesi.

Definately

[andyZOR]

Morales
Jones Jr.
Holyfield
Bowe
Mesi
Castillo
Hopkins
DLH
Mosley
Judah


Explain in bold please.

[myk]

Those that have been fighting not more than once a year

[Jambon]

Larry Merchant and Teddy Atlas.