To Dipper Brown - Yes or No Answer and no more "Tarver is a joke" posts!

[KO Boxing]

This is a simple yes or no question. No excuses, no bullshit, singing, no dancing or talking in circles, just YES or NO!

If you can answer this question without all the usual bullshit excuses, I will make this my last "Tarver is a one-hit wonder joke" post on ESB.




1) Is Trevor Berbick better than Mohammed Ali, YES or NO!!!!

2) Is Brian Neilson better than Larry Holmes, YES or NO!!!


p.s. Your answer to these questions answer the question to your other thread.

[KO Boxing]

Well, I think Trevor Berbick is dead now, I believe.

If he is not, hell yeah he'd kick Muhammed Ali's shaky ass up and down and all around the ring.

The same probably goes for Brian Neilson vs Larry Holmes.
:lol:

I said, YES or NO!!! No excuses...

So:

Tarver is a joke...

Tarver is a one-hit wonder...

Tarver looks like a milk-dud...

Tarver = Second-coming of Buster Douglas...

:good

[KO Boxing]

I believe.

If he is not

probaby

And the best one:
if they fought tomorrow
I'm sorry, I said YES or NO!!! No excuses.

Let the bashing fly!

:bbb

[KO Boxing]

I will never trust a ESB poster again.
Why? Cause you got owned by someone using your very same standards?

You asked a simple Yes or No question. Is Tarver better than Roy?

No explanantions, no excuses, no nothing. JUST a yes, or a no.

I asked the EXACT same simple Yes or No question. Is Trevor Berbick better than Muhammed Ali?

Not tomorrow night, not if he wasn't dead, not if nothing. JUST a yes, or a no. And if one question isn't enough for you, how about: Is Brian Neilson better than Larry Holmes? Again, JUST a yes or a no. No "probably the same goes for" bullsh!t. Just YES or NO... Like YOUR question, :yep


Just for the record, my answer to ALL 3 questions is a resounding NO! As ANY respectable boxing fan should agree with.

Thank you and good night... :hi:

[JoeyP]

Get him to post his round by round scoring of the first RJJ fight ---you get even more excuses.

[codeman99998]

In all fairness, there is the POSSIBILITY that Tarver just has Roy's number.

Vernon Forrest and Shane Mosley is a great example. Sometimes one fighter is just MADE to beat another, but it doesn't make him greater. There is definitely an argument that Tarver is better than Jones, however, there is no argument that Tarver is greater than Jones.

[KillerInstinct]

Get him to post his round by round scoring of the first RJJ fight ---you get even more excuses.

Dipper conveniently "looses" his scorecard when someone asks to see it.