Pernell Whitaker V Ray Robinson

[TIGEREDGE]

i fancy sweet pea to be able to beat the greatest ever. But i reckon sugar ray would figure him out and destroy him in a rematch

[Street Lethal]

Robinson is peerless at 147 pounds.

[Robbi]

At 147 Whitaker was not the Sweet Pea of 135, Robinson by UD. P4P, the Pea at 135 may have beaten the Robinson of 147 though, can't really say. But yeah, at 147 Robinson wins this one.


Whitaker at 135lbs against Robinson at 147lbs is an unfair match. While Whitaker would present Robinson with serious problems, not sure he could pull out a victory.

But shrink Robinson by putting him in a washing machine, then tumble dry him on full spin, and out he comes at 135lbs with comparable power at lightweight. Whitaker would beat him if both were exactly the same size. It would be one hell of a close fight, but I'd side with Whitaker.

[rekcutnevets]

Robinson's size and power would be too much for Whitaker to overcome in this one. The impact of Robinson's punch would be the difference in any scenario you want for a Robinson victory. You can argue he'd land the cleaner blows to win a decision, you can argue he would knock him out.

Whitaker is my favorite fighter from the 90's, so I going to give him the benefit of the doubt in going the distance. The only time he was stopped was in his last fight, and he threw out his shoulder in that one.

[Executioner]

At 147 Robinson might just stop Whitaker. A ferocious hitter + blinding speed + amazing skill and being the naturally bigger man .. I predict Robinson stops him late.

[Robbi]

Apart from power, Whitaker measures up well talent wise against Robinson. Probably better defense, and while Robinson gets credit for boxing well on the backfoot, not quite as good as Whitaker from what I have seen.

Robinson's knockout blow against Fullmer in the rematch was not delivered while going backwards as everyone likes to put it. Robinson was moving backwards, then stopped before firing the left hook which had Fullmer out. Its made out as if he let loose with the left hook on Fullmer's chin when moving backwards at the same time. Not the case.

[Mantequilla]

Robinson would beat Whitaker pretty thoroughly at Welter, and win a clear, but hard-fought decision P4P.

[GazOC]

Robinson is peerless at 147 pounds.
:good IMHO nobody beats Robinson at 147.

[Robbi]

Nobody stops a prime Whitaker though, it would be a decision for Robinson.

Whitaker was not in his prime at 147lbs, and if your prediction is a mythical match between Robinson at 147lbs and Whitaker at 135lbs. Its simply crazy and would not be sanctioned. Lets have them the both both squaring off prime for prime the same size, still crazy but easier to make a fair comparison. Whitaker doesn't get stopped, I think he'd win.

[Bummy Davis]

SSR ko by the 10th

[brooklyn1550]

At 147, Robinson by UD

[Executioner]

Nobody stops a prime Whitaker though.

That's no guarantee. :deal