Bad Judges name and shame them

[LHL]

I was just looking through the Boxrec judges record and seen Daniel Talon has handed in some really strange score cards like:

Sturm Vs Gevor - 117 - 111 (Can't see how he scored it so wide)

Sprott Vs Dettweiler - 111 - 115 (the other 2 give to Sprott although i haven't seen the fight i could guess who was supposed to win and what really happened)

Sidorenko Vs Cardoba - 118 - 111 (the other two had it a draw)

[kosaros]

That Brit who scored the recent Chambers fight a draw.

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

He scored the Chambers fight 113-113, even when it was clear Chambers won almost every round and scored two knockdowns. Apparently some of his other judging decisions have been just as bad.

[Losfer_Words]

The British dude who scored Chambers-Dimitrenko 113-113:

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

According to the Yanks on the general, this bloke has produced some dodgy scorecards in the past as well.

[kosaros]

The British dude who scored Chambers-Dimitrenko 113-113:

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

According to the Yanks on the general, this bloke has produced some dodgy scorecards in the past as well.

Beat you to it again Losfer :yep:good

[Losfer_Words]

Beat you to it again Losfer :yep:good

Not really as you provided no source, mate. I win:good:yep.

[kosaros]

Not really as you provided no source, mate. I win:good:yep.

What are you talking about? :D

[Losfer_Words]

What are you talking about? :D

I spent more time typing mine:bart. You just can't waltz in here stealing my opinions, Kos:nono. I reckon you're snooping my PC:?.

[LHL]

Just looked through it and the Chambers one looks the only one maybe Reid of Calzaghe but people argue that Reid won (personally i had Joe)

[LHL]

I spent more time typing mine:bart. You just can't waltz in here stealing my opinions, Kos:nono. I reckon you're snooping my PC:?.

:rofl You' 2 are always at this

[kosaros]

I spent more time typing mine:bart. You just can't waltz in here stealing my opinions, Kos:nono. I reckon you're snooping my PC:?.

Look again. :yep:good

[LHL]

Look again. :yep:good

:lol: Wonder where all that additional info came from

[Losfer_Words]

:rofl You' 2 are always at this

Yep.:lol: It is just banter though- can't you tell by the excessive use of smilies?;):gayfight

[Losfer_Words]

Look again. :yep:good

:lol:I love your creative use of the edit tool.:patsch:nono

[kosaros]

:lol:I love your creative use of the edit tool.:patsch:nono

If I edited, would it not say that I edited it? :D

No evidence at all that I did 'alter' my post. :good

[Losfer_Words]

If I edited, would it not say that I edited it? :D

No evidence at all that I did 'alter' my post. :good

No, I must be mistaken. I also never saw any reference to AIDS yesterday either:roll::D.

[kosaros]

No, I must be mistaken. I also never saw any reference to AIDS yesterday either:roll::D.

:lol::lol::lol:

[LHL]

Its hard to find a constantly dodgy judge

[safc1990]

I think it was Bob Logist who gave Tito 3 of the first 4 rounds against De La Hoya then gave Oscar the 12th round. I think that alone suggests something dodgy was definitely afoot that night.

[LHL]

I think it was Bob Logist who gave Tito 3 of the first 4 rounds against De La Hoya then gave Oscar the 12th round. I think that alone suggests something dodgy was definitely afoot that night.

You have to ask what fight was he watching

[ishy]

Doug Tucker
[Only registered and activated users can see links]

Scored Mijares-Navarro 120-108 for Navarro :huh

[safc1990]

Doug Tucker
[Only registered and activated users can see links]

Scored Mijares-Navarro 120-108 for Navarro :huh

Didn't he also have Barrera-Marquez a near shutout for Marquez?

[LHL]

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

They nicked my thread and my Talon one :lol: and yours Ishy

[LHL]

Robert Hoyle gives the odd crazy scorecard:

Ngoudjo vs Urango - 106 - 120 (was close but clear not a shut out)
De Leon Vs Escobedo - 118 - 110 (I had Escobedo that night he out box de leon easily)
Forbes Vs Hopkins - 110 - 118 (I had Forbes in this thought it was terrible scoring)

[safc1990]

I had Escobedo by that score.....

Michael Alexander's record of scoring fights here is disgraceful, I think he is actually a robot programmed to score the round 10-9 to the house fighter.

Other than that, Eugenia Williams - THREAD CLOSED!

Isn't that him who seems to think that all Haye fans are racist haters of Wlad? :lol::lol:

[Lee Mc]

Jose Juan Guerra 110-118 Leonard over Hagler!

O.k. I know this has the ability to create hell and I apologise in advance.

But how anyone could give that fight to Leonard by 8 rounds I'll never know. I had Leonard winning by 3 in a VERY close fight that could have gone either way but all the controversy comes from Guerra's card in my opinion.

[safc1990]

Jose Juan Guerra 110-118 Leonard over Hagler!

O.k. I know this has the ability to create hell and I apologise in advance.

But how anyone could give that fight to Leonard by 8 rounds I'll never know. I had Leonard winning by 3 in a VERY close fight that could have gone either way but all the controversy comes from Guerra's card in my opinion.

Agreed. The ironic thing is that Guerra was only brought in because of an objection by the Hagler camp to one of the original judges.

[Lee Mc]

Agreed. The ironic thing is that Guerra was only brought in because of an objection by the Hagler camp to one of the original judges.

According to some it was because he was British and Hagler hated British people because of the Wembley riot. (Though I tend tofind myself agreeing with those who suggest that Hagler believed a Mexican judge would appreciate his style more) However, Harry Gibbs watching the fight in England, scored it 116-114 to Hagler which, of course, would have been a split decision victory to him!