how would malignaggi do against these guys.....

[Relentless]

cotto - in another 4 or 5 years time

floyd mayweather - 4 or 5 years time

clottey - now

margarito - now

kermit cintron - now

[Brooklyn Boxer]

I think Paulie would beat clottey and margarito now. cintron is a toss up now. paulie should beat cotto in 4 to 5 years from now because he almost beat cotto last year. i know people are going to say paulie got beaten up but he lost by 2 and 3 rounds. Floyd will be retire by 4 or 5 years so it wont happen and if they fought paulie would win because floyd would be way past his prime.

[brooklyn1550]

I'm not sure how he would do as a welterweight - I could see all of them beating him.

[semichin]

I think Paulie would beat clottey and margarito now. cintron is a toss up now. paulie should beat cotto in 4 to 5 years from now because he almost beat cotto last year. i know people are going to say paulie got beaten up but he lost by 2 and 3 rounds. Floyd will be retire by 4 or 5 years so it wont happen and if they fought paulie would win because floyd would be way past his prime.:yep

[Marnoff]

cotto - in another 4 or 5 years time

floyd mayweather - 4 or 5 years time

clottey - now

margarito - now

kermit cintron - now

Cotto and Floyd will still beat him.

It is conceivable that he gets by the other three now.

[Illmatic]

all losses

[warrior85]

lose

[LeedsLad]

Besides Clottey, id favour all of them to beat him. Certainly Cotto and Mayweather would put a beat down on him at any time.

[liljp361]

Depends how far he progresses...I think he can be so much better especially if he had more of a killer instinct. Thats all he needs really...but instead he usually likes to make his opponenents feel helpless by keeping his distance set with a jab that can be thrown from virtually any angle at any speed he knows a thing or 2 about using his jab definitley. he has very quick hands...once he has that distance set he can virtually control the whole fight. He just needs to want to hurt his opponent more than he does is all lol.

[liljp361]

You think he beats Clottey?

Either Clottey wins or it will be a boring fight.

[Relentless]

he'll never beat cotto, cotto will always be his daddy, he couldn't beat him when he was weight drained.

[DoumB]

some ppl underate Paulie, He would win most of these except maybe floyd and MAYBE cotto who he was matching pretty well

[41fever]

cotto - in another 4 or 5 years time

floyd mayweather - 4 or 5 years time

clottey - now

margarito - now

kermit cintron - now
stay away from Kermit and Margarito, he'll eventually get hammered by both, strong probability within 12 rds...with PBF and COTTO in time, well, depends how he matures...I think think he'll be at least competitive with the smaller two, today or tomorrow

[41fever]

Clottey, he has a chance, just stay on the tricycle

[Still~style]

all of them are too strong for paulie.

[41fever]

for PM, i think unification in his weight division looks very very good! TORRES, WITTER, maybe HATTON, ...

[El Bombasto]

cotto - in another 4 or 5 years time

floyd mayweather - 4 or 5 years time

clottey - now

margarito - now

kermit cintron - now

Malignaggi UD Cotto 4-5 years from now (Cotto's style will age him rapidly, Malinaggi's won't)

PBF 4-5 years from now UD Malignaggi (although I do not expect PBF to still be boxing 4-5 years from now, Malignaggi has done nothing to suggest he would be able to beat any version of Floyd)

Malignaggi UD Clotty now (Clottey will fade)

Margarito UD Malignaggi (this would actually be a good fight, though it wouldn't sell well. Margarito is a little too big for Malignaggi)

Cintron KO Malignaggi (Cintron too big and powerful)

[Liston3]

I could see Malignaggi beating any of those fighters, he is very skilled