P4P - Where is Hatton now?

[dangerousity]

I have him no.7 at the moment but a good case could be made for him being 3. I wonder where Ring will put him.

[unitas]

22.

[KO Boxing]

I have him no. 8, and have no problem seeing him as high as no. 6. I think having him break into the top 5 at the moment is a little much, though... With PBF, Manny, Winky, the Marquez bros, and B-Hop all around.

[Jimbo]

Put this is another thread.

I'd say at least #5

1. PBF
2. Pac
3. Winky
4. JMM
5. Hatton
6. B-Hop
7. Calzaghe
8. Cotto
9. Rafa Marquez
10. Taylor/Mosley

[Jimbo]

I'm happy with him anywhere 5-8. I have him maybe 7 now. Still only the number 2 Brit on the list though...

Talent-wise agreed but I think this puts him above Calzaghe in terms of quality of opposition, especially recently.

[McGrain]

I have him splitting the Marquez brothers at number 4.

I know that puts me in the minority, but the may I see it, if he beats Cotto, then he's three, if he beats Mayweather then he's two. So four is a comfy spot for him.

[McGrain]

I'm happy with him anywhere 5-8. I have him maybe 7 now. Still only the number 2 Brit on the list though...


I think he burries Cal p4p. You have to take his achievments into account friend, and I wouldn't even have Cal above Ricky in that department if he beats Kessler. They've just followed different career paths - Hatton's has seen mow through the game's second tier plus two world class fighters - Calzaghe's been campaigning two slots below that, with one world class fighter.

[Danny Ocean]

1.Mayweather
2.Winky
3.Pacman
4.J Marquez
5.Hopkins
6.Taylor
7.Hatton
8.Marco Barrera
9.Rafa Marquez
10.Miguel Cotto#

[McGrain]

Is it just me or is JMM suddenly overrated? I'm impressed with Rafael's moving up to take Vasquez (who I hold in high esteem), but I think JMM's win over MAB said more about Barrera. I'm just not convinced he's a top 5 p4p guy.


I think he is a tad overated, yes. Though i do have him at 5. I actually think he's the weaker of the two brothers, although most have things the other way around.

[dangerousity]

I can see him at 4 easily. His wins over Kostya & Castillo has gotta be more than a match for JMM win over MAB & Rafa's win over Israel & Johnson+Austin.

[dangerousity]

I think he is a tad overated, yes. Though i do have him at 5. I actually think he's the weaker of the two brothers, although most have things the other way around.

I disagree. JMM IMO has tougher comp than his brother. Whereas Rafa has A level fighters to deal with, JMM has HOF & ATG's. Had JMM got a hold of Morales & MAB early (possibly beat them) and got the nod over Pac, we can all very easily see him as no.1. I guess Rafa has had less hiccups than his bro.

[Relentless]

no way is he higher than cotto!

[jmarti14]

no way is he higher than cotto!

agreed!!

[deram]

On skill or achievement?

On achievement he edges Cotto.

On skill he is just outside top 20.

[Relentless]

so?? hatton shouldn't have vacated it and should have fought cotto, didn't hatton win a vacated ibo belt?? i wonder who vacated that?

[dangerousity]

C'mon, no way of justifying Cotto being higher than Hatton p4p. Cotto is currently my 2nd fav fighter after Pac but Hatton's wins over Kostya & Castillo just overshadows Cotto's win over Judah. Castillo is also no more shot than Judah, just look at the results of their last few fights.

Relentless didnt you pick Castillo to destroy Hatton? As it stands, the opposite just happened.

[Relentless]

C'mon, no way of justifying Cotto being higher than Hatton p4p. Cotto is currently my 2nd fav fighter after Pac but Hatton's wins over Kostya & Castillo just overshadows Cotto's win over Judah. Castillo is also no more shot than Judah, just look at the results of their last few fights.

Relentless didnt you pick Castillo to destroy Hatton? As it stands, the opposite just happened.

i didn't really pick castillo to destroy hatton, the thread was a parody of arrans 'hatton will destroy castillo'

this fight didn't really interest me.


face it cotto is the man:smoke

[murrayhart2007]

My P4P Top Ten

1. Mayweather
2. Pac
3. Winky
4. Marquez
5. Mosley
6. Hatton
7. Cotto
8. Taylor/Spinks
9. Calzaghe
10. B-Hop

[hellblazer]

My Top 10 P4P
1)Manny Pacquiao
2)Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3)Rafael Marquez
4)Winky Wright
5)Ricky Hatton
6)Joe Calzaghe
7)Jermain Taylor
8 )Miguel Cotto
9)Marco Antonio Barrera
10)Bernard Hopkins

:bbb

[Anthony Farnell]

Dangerousity,
Who's the girl in your avatar :love

[1boricua]

1 Manny Pacquiao
2 Rafael Marquez
3 Juan Manuel Marquez
4 Winky Wright
5 Floyd Mayweather
6 Bernard Hopkins
7 Joe Calzaghe
8 Shane Mosley
9 Miguel Cotto
10 Ricky Hatton

[sonny73]

I have him splitting the Marquez brothers at number 4.

I know that puts me in the minority, but the may I see it, if he beats Cotto, then he's three, if he beats Mayweather then he's two. So four is a comfy spot for him.
yeah right if he beats Mayweather and Cotto,then he has beaten every top guy in and around his weight,forget about your little Ring Magazine P4P number one spot he would go down as one of the top 3 guys ever to fight at below middleweight

[RafaelGonzal]

How the hell is Hatton above Cotto in the scheme of things at P4P
you guys are so obvious, fans are the worse be objective dammit!!

[elias]

I like Cotto but only an idiot would think he should be above Hatton.

[sonny73]

Definitely not above Cotto. 140 is a pretty weak division.
weak is not the word...tidy after Hatton has cleaned it out

[BigEars]

I like it that people are starting to give Rafael Marquez his dues , he dominated down at Bantamweight and is now the Super Bantamweight king .

Not to mention he's one of the most exciting fighters out there and his rematch with Israel Vasquez is destined to be a belter .

As for Hatton in my lb 4 lb , probably #5

[Beatboxer]

8th before last night

ill have to have a think about it now whether he should go up a few

[achillesthegreat]

Floyd, Winky and Pac are definitely above him. I think he can challenge for 4 to 8.

[Executioner]

How the hell is Hatton above Cotto in the scheme of things at P4P
you guys are so obvious, fans are the worse be objective dammit!!

Are you for real? Hatton's win over Tszyu alone shits all over anything Cotto has done.

[Executioner]

stupid double post.

[Relentless]

Are you for real? Hatton's win over Tszyu alone shits all over anything Cotto has done.

hey didn't you do a permenant ban bet on de la hoya vs mayweather on radars thread?

[Executioner]

hey didn't you do a permenant ban bet on de la hoya vs mayweather on radars thread?

I did a month off bet. I kept saying Floyd would win the fight but radar kept listing me under the people that picked DLH and his reasoning for it is because he thought I was Widdow_MaKers cousin :conf

[Relentless]

I did a month off bet. I kept saying Floyd would win the fight but radar kept listing me under the people that picked DLH and his reasoning for it is because he thought I was Widdow_MaKers cousin :conf

:rofl

[Jack]

Cotto isn't top 10, never mind ahead of Hatton. He looks good, yes, but his best win is against someone who was outpointed by Carlos fucking Baldomir and hasn't won a fight in over two years.

I'd probably have Hatton around 5.

[Executioner]

:rofl


:lol: