-My Top 10 P4P-

[liljp361]

1-Floyd Mayweather
2-Manny Pacquiao
3-Joe Calzaghe
4-Rafael Marquez
5-Winky Wright
6-Bernard Hopkins
7-Shane Mosley
8-Miguel Cotto
9-Ricky Hatton
10-Juan Diaz

Any name I would consider replacing in there would be: Jermain Taylor or Wladimir Klitschko (after this Sat.) or the winner of Margarito - Williams.

:deal

[Stinky gloves]

Calzaghe, Wright, Hopkins down
Cotto, Hatton up

[Throwing doubles]

Replace Calzaghe with Kessler or you'll be a laughing stock in four months...

[brooklyn1550]

1. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Rafael Marquez
4. Winky Wright
5. Juan Manuel Marquez
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Ricky Hatton
8. Miguel Cotto
9. Joe Calzaghe
10. Marco Antonio Barrera

[Stinky gloves]

Calzaghe down??
At #5 for example?

He may be #3 if he beat Kessler.

[liljp361]

Why not Calzaghe at #3...

[Throwing doubles]

He won't last the distance with Kessler... One good fight against overrated Lacy doesn't make him P4P 3rd. Look at the rest og his record. Floored against Salem and Mitchell. Kessler will kill him.

[liljp361]

He won't last the distance with Kessler... One good fight against overrated Lacy doesn't make him P4P 3rd. Look at the rest og his record. Floored against Salem and Mitchell. Kessler will kill him.

Calzaghe UD :D

[Stinky gloves]

Why not Calzaghe at #3...
He isn't a dominat champion at his own weight class, at least untill he
beat Kessler so I guess he is at #5 on my list, below PBF, PAC, Marquez, Hopkins.

[mike464]

Mayweather
Wright
Pacquiao
Hatton
Taylor
Hopkins
J M Marquez
R Marquez
Mosley
Calzaghe

Cotto and Kessler almost make it

[liljp361]

Mosley and Hatton should not be in there.

Wlad Klit is in my 10 p4p.

Maybe after Saturday lol

[Stinky gloves]

you mean if wlad wins?

Are you going to put him into top p4p if he loses?

[liljp361]

Are you going to put him into top p4p if he loses?
lol

[China_hand_Joe]

1-Floyd Mayweather
2-Manny Pacquiao
3-Joe Calzaghe
4-Rafael Marquez
5-Winky Wright


:dealI'm pretty much in agreement with the first 5 more or less. Don't listen to the people saying put Calzaghe down. That is insanity if you compare him with the fighters they'd replace him with. It is very difficult to put Marquez, Winky (at this point in his career) above Joe. You can even use the ability argument to put Joe top in my opinion.

[liljp361]

I'm pretty much in agreement with the first 5 more or less. Don't listen to the people saying put Calzaghe down. That is insanity if you compare him with the fighters they'd replace him with. It is very difficult to put Marquez, Winky (at this point in his career) above Joe. You can even use the ability argument to put Joe top in my opinion.

Whats your next 5?

[MagnificentMatt]

HAH...He said Winky at this point in his career? What about Calzaghe at THIS point in HIS career!

[liljp361]

HAH...He said Winky at this point in his career? What about Calzaghe at THIS point in HIS career!

I dont think theres anybody Id pick from 160-168 that can beat Joe Calzaghe..

[Executioner]

Why is Cotto ahead of Hatton? Hatton now has two TKO's over Pound For Pounders and one an ATG. Cotto has a win over Judah who got starched in 2 rounds by a guy Hatton brutalized.

Judah also lost 3 of his last 4 fights.

[China_hand_Joe]

Whats your next 5?I'm very fickle on my next 5. I even manage to get Kessler (partly due to uterior motives) in there depending on my mood.

[mightyd40]

taylor should be in everybodys list.....he hasnt look great lately but he does hold wins over bhop and wright and is still undefeated

[The Italarican]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Jermain Taylor
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. Rafael Marquez
8. Ricky Hatton
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Shane Mosley

I have Taylor on a probationary period and am giving him one more chance before he takes a fall, perhaps a big one. The Winky-Jermain-Hopkins combo at 3-4-5 is based greatly on the closeness of Taylor's bouts with Winky and Hopkins. That will change soon with Wright-Hopkins and it now being 2 years since Hopkins-Taylor 1.

[venbox]

taylor should be in everybodys list.....he hasnt look great lately but he does hold wins over bhop and wright and is still undefeated
Last time I checked, Winky-Taylor was declared a draw (and a gift draw for Jermain , if you ask me). The Hopkins wins weren't very decisive either.

[mightyd40]

Last time I checked, Winky-Taylor was declared a draw (and a gift draw for Jermain , if you ask me). The Hopkins wins weren't very decisive either.
my bad i meant to say that, but i think jermain won against wright honestly.......and as for hopkins think what u want but a wins a win

[DanePugilist]

P4P by skill not resume.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. PBF.
3. Joe Calzaghe.
4. Rafael Marquez
5. Kessler.
6. Miguel Cotto
7. Winky.
8. JMM.
9. Cristian Mijares.
10. Klitschko.

[sues2nd]

1- Floyd
2- Pac
3- Raph Marquez
4- Winky
5- Taylor
6- Hopkins
7- Calzaghe
8- Hatton
9- Mosley
10- Cotto

NOW THAT IS A DAMN GOOD LIST!

:D

[BigEars]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Rafael Marquez
4.Winky Wright
5.Ricky Hatton
6.Joe Calzaghe
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Juan Manuel Marquez
9.Jermain Taylor
10.Shane Mosley

Some may disagree but opinions are like arseholes..............

I think most of the lists people have submitted would have a reasonable argument for being right .

[liljp361]

I honestly think my p4p list is the best.