HBO and their judges.

[DoumB]

Hmm WTF? JT was ahead on the scorecards? gimmi a break


round 1. real close with pavlik landing more I think, Ill give it to Taylor 10-9(generous as fuck)
round 2 10-8 JT
round 3 10-10 generous again
round 4 10-9 pavlik
round 5 10-9 pavlik
round 6 10-9 pavlik

I was generous for Taylor and the score says draw, and I was real generous, those scorecards were bullshit, didnt someone say they were like 4-2 for taylor????

[safe_pa]

I suppose it could be seen that way, personally I had JT ahead at the time.
I'm also British so neutral to both fighters.

[pipe wrenched]

KP was down by 3 points on two and 4 on another if I heard it right.

[Danny Ocean]

I know. I had Pavlik dominating every single round except for the 2nd round when Pavlik pulled a mayorga and let taylor hit him. He got caught with a lucky punch that's all.+


:rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :patsch

[o_money]

KP was down by 3 points on two and 4 on another if I heard it right.

yeah thats pretty rediculous. Thank god kelly stopped him cause I don't think I could have taken another contraversial taylor win.

Not that I actually think he lost the spinks, wright, or either hopkins fights but that would be one too many.

[MrStayman]

I thought it was a robbery at first as well. But when I watched the fight again I realized I was getting caught up in the crowd hype + lederman. Round 6 (I think. It was one of them anyways) was given to Pavlik, and Taylor out landed him by 20 shots. I agree with Merchant - going into the 7th it was 3-3, with Taylor up by 1 point. 3 points is a bit of a stretch, but it wasn't clearly Pavlik's.

[Rickypr18]

I thought it was a robbery at first as well. But when I watched the fight again I realized I was getting caught up in the crowd hype + lederman. Round 6 (I think. It was one of them anyways) was given to Pavlik, and Taylor out landed him by 20 shots. I agree with Merchant - going into the 7th it was 3-3, with Taylor up by 1 point. 3 points is a bit of a stretch, but it wasn't clearly Pavlik's.
I agree, I had it 3-3 with Taylor up by 1 point because of the KD. There is no way in hell that Taylor was up by 3 points.

[MrStayman]

I agree, I had it 3-3 with Taylor up by 1 point because of the KD. There is no way in hell that Taylor was up by 3 points.

Well, that's only a 1 round difference. Pavlik won 1 and 3 hands down. Taylor won 2 and 5 hands down. The contested rounds were 4 and 6. I can fathom a judge giving them both to Taylor after looking at them again.

The real killer is that the woman gave round 1 to Taylor though. Pavlik DOMINATED Taylor in compubox numbers in that round. He connected at a higher rate and landed something like 20 more power shots. Pavlik, the sidewalk guy, Lederman, Steward and Taylor all agreed openly who won that round.

[Boom_Boom]

I agree, I had it 3-3 with Taylor up by 1 point because of the KD. There is no way in hell that Taylor was up by 3 points.

oh so you followed my advice last night and rewatched that fight now huh, good for you :thumbsup


Those who are saying Pavlik was dominating are reaching out of their asses.

[Dorfmeister]

Pharmacist Lederman is going catatonic at a fast pace the way he had it 4 rounds to 2 to Kelly and the way he had Winky winning cause Bernard was doing "too much clinching" ( he says), maybe Harold is on drugstore dope!

[achillesthegreat]

I don't see Taylor the way the judges did. He had a big second and maybe one other round.

[DoumB]

I don't see Taylor the way the judges did. He had a big second and maybe one other round.

thats what I tought too, I gave him 3 at max.