Once and for all: Who is currently the top Super Featherweight ?

[doknochrisan]

Soto
Valero
Guzman
MAB
JMM
PAC

You can rate them from top to bottom if you want.

[psychopath]

It's got to be JMM and Pacquaio.

You'll get the answer who among the two . . . once they fight.

There's no way Valero, Guzman and Soto can vie for the top spot at this point . . . because they are untested against top level opponents.

[brooklyn1550]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Barrera
4. Guzman
5. Soto
6. Valero

[chimba]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Barrera
4. Guzman
5. Soto
6. Valero

Brooklyn you are the best!:good Not because you have Pac as #1 but having MAB at 3. This shows real wisdom. You should be President of this fuckin Forums

[Wige247]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Soto
4. Barrera
5. Guzman
6. Valero

[doknochrisan]

It's got to be JMM and Pacquaio.

You'll get the answer who among the two . . . once they fight.

There's no way Valero, Guzman and Soto can vie for the top spot at this point . . . because they are untested against top level opponents.

Who is your top pick if you were to choose only one?

[41fever]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Barrera
4. Guzman
5. Soto
6. Valerothat looks good.

[brooklyn1550]

Brooklyn you are the best!:good Not because you have Pac as #1 but having MAB at 3. This shows real wisdom. You should be President of this fuckin Forums

:lol:

[kg0208]

Pacman
JMM
Guzman
MAB
Soto
Valero

[PATSYS]

Soto
Valero
Guzman
MAB
JMM
PAC

You can rate them from top to bottom if you want.

Pac by far.

The rest are more or less the same level. JMM can not claim a higher spot, he's only got 1 fight at SFW and he won closely. I mean it is not like he demolished MAB. Juarez cam close to beating a younger MAB too.

[doknochrisan]

Funny how they rate JMM after PAC where in most posters give Guzman the edge over El Dinamita to beat PAC on the other thread.

[chimba]

Funny how they rate JMM after PAC where in most posters give Guzman the edge over El Dinamita to beat PAC on the other thread.

Its the styles, Guzmans wide looping punches are a perfect antidote for Pacs blinding left straight:hey

[psychopath]

Who is your top pick if you were to choose only one?

JMM . . . because he has a legititmate belt. :yep

[PacDbest]

Pac -Far ahead, He might abandoned 130 after MAB. Reason??? Mab was rated top 3-4 130 by most & yet Nobody's Giving him a Chance against Pac. Tickets still available coz a lot of people refused to Pay for Non Competitve fight. This MAB is the same who fought Neck to neck with everybody's #2 in JMM. If Pac dominated MAB again in a one sided Beating & older JMM ask for Big slice of the Pie to fight Pac, I see Pac jumping to 135 the next fight to fight Diazes or Katsidis. It's up to JMM, Guzman & Valero to follow the Money trail of Pac at 135 if they're really willing to fight Pac.

[hellblazer]

Emmanuel D. Pacquiao of course :yep

[saul_ir34]

1. Marquez - he has the title I dont see Pac with any titles. They drew last time so hes got the upper hand.
2. Pacquiao - no titles but #1 contender
3. Barrera - Still more tested and more skilled than the rest of those
4. Soto
5. Guzman - soto vs guzman will decide who is higher
6. Valero - hot prospect who hasnt been tested yet

This list will change though within the next few months....

[Morrissey]

Pac. Even without a belt, he is at no. 2 P2P. You don't make him the second banana in his division just because he has no belt.
JMM. Has a belt, and also in p4p list.

The rest are all in the same spots.

[Asterion]

1. Pacman
2. JMM

[theunderdog]

1. Marquez - he has the title I dont see Pac with any titles. They drew last time so hes got the upper hand.
2. Pacquiao - no titles but #1 contender
3. Barrera - Still more tested and more skilled than the rest of those
4. Soto
5. Guzman - soto vs guzman will decide who is higher
6. Valero - hot prospect who hasnt been tested yet

This list will change though within the next few months....

so that's you reasoning? pac does not have a belt so he is not the best. damn man. that's stupid. you know that pac could have easily beaten paper champ mzokne fana if he wanted a belt.

[darkness]

Marquez slightly ahead of Pac. They need to fight to settle it.

[doknochrisan]

Chris John could be top 3 superfeather. He'd outbox Guzman and humiliate Valero. I think Soto might catch him and knock him out. Pacquiao would stop him, and Marquez is a toss up. John would UD Barrera.

Unless he fights in a neutral place he could never be up there.

[mad_takamura]

Chris John could be top 3 superfeather. He'd outbox Guzman and humiliate Valero. I think Soto might catch him and knock him out. Pacquiao would stop him, and Marquez is a toss up. John would UD Barrera. so what's your point?
anyways pac is number 1 simply because: he's exciting to watch, young and has the better resume of the other competition.
jmm? only 1 fight against an aging mab
guz? where is his so called "tyson-like power" now at sf?
valero? nice competion: he should raise the level up by fighting truck drivers next!
soto? who did he beat in 130? aa ok: bobby pac! of course he's popular, yep he is indeed.... popular.
mab? defeated fana (who?),defeated peden who lost to a pinoy journeyman ganoy, lost to juarez (yes he lost don't argue :nono), defeated juarez by running away in a boring decision, defeated by jmm in a ud in a championship match.

i ain't nuthugging: am i??

[reed_man02]

Pac. Even without a belt, he is at no. 2 P2P. You don't make him the second banana in his division just because he has no belt.
JMM. Has a belt, and also in p4p list.

The rest are all in the same spots.

Him being P4P #2 doesnt matter as he earn that position at lower weights. JMM beat the top dog at 130 so he becomes the top dog. :yep

[Still~style]

dpeneds ont he eye of the beholder. in the media i say pacqiou is regarded as no. 1. but we need to see more fights. i like soto.

[doknochrisan]

Seems like the fucking ABC's dont count anymore as what most of the posters here believe.

[Spitfire7]

Any self-respecting fan knows who's the man at SFW.