Calzaghe top3 PvP after Nov3

[yesihavearm]

After Calzaghe beats Kessler on november 3rd, will he be regarded as the Number 3 on everyones PvP lists behind Gayweather and PAC ?

It seems that most people now have him around about the 5th-6th mark.

[China_hand_Joe]

No, they'll keep him at 5th or 6th at the highest, even with a shut-out win.

[Smazz20]

Depends on the fight. Convincing win might move him to 3rd. Hard fought maybe only 4th or 5th.

[PrideOfWales]

A win for Joe and Kessler will be over-rated, adding fuel to the "he only fights bums" fire therefore will be relegated to 7-8 on the p4p list.

At least in the USA of America anyway mate.

[Rollo]

Calzaghe won´t beat Kessler - and you know that already!

[yesihavearm]

No, they'll keep him at 5th or 6th at the highest, even with a shut-out win.

yeah thats what I was afraid of. Seems no matter what Joe does he wont get the recognition.

It's sad to think that Calzaghe could go over to the states and beat Hopkins - Pavlik - Dawson and still people wouldnt put him higher saying things such as Hopkins too old, Pavlik couldnt carry the weight, Dawson was overated.

[rydersonthestorm]

Well since pacman is fighting mab instead of a proper challenge like jmm, i don;t see wy he should saty at number 2 in the rankings.

[yesihavearm]

Well since pacman is fighting mab instead of a proper challenge like jmm, i don;t see wy he should saty at number 2 in the rankings.

Good point. If PAC doesnt fight JMM next im gonna go insane, PAC is at a peak and should be going for legacy.

[BewareofDawg]

No, they'll keep him at 5th or 6th at the highest, even with a shut-out win.
Let me ask you this; what if Mosley shuts out cotto? Should Mosley be higher then Joe? He will be on my list :deal

[China_hand_Joe]

Mosley has little chance against Cotto though, mate.

Cotto will get more credit than either Calzaghe or Kessler though, even though both are superior to Mosley at this point in time, without his steroids or whatever.