How many does Eder Jofre win vs the following 10 ATG's ? [Archive]

Mendoza

10-06-2007, 07:51 AM

How many does Bantam Weight Eder Jofre win vs the following ten all time greats between the weights of 115-122 pounds! The field is stacked. Take the poll. You can vote however you choose. I will try to make the thread public to avoid the ludicrous 1’s and 10’s votes.

The ten fighters are:

George Dixon

Terry McGovern

Panama Al Brown

Mauel Ortiz

Fighting Harda

Ruben Olivares

Sandy Sadler

Salvador Sanchez

Jeff Fenech

Carlos Zarte

mcvey

10-06-2007, 10:44 AM

How many does Bantam Weight Eder Jofre win vs the following ten all time greats between the weights of 115-122 pounds! The field is stacked. Take the poll. You can vote however you choose. I will try to make the thread public to avoid the ludicrous 1’s and 10’s votes.

The ten fighters are:

George Dixon

Terry McGovern

Panama Al Brown

Mauel Ortiz

Fighting Harda

Ruben Olivares

Sandy Sadler

Salvador Sanchez

Jeff Fenech

Carlos Zarte
Love that Fighting Harda! What a ring name!.

teeto

10-23-2007, 05:47 AM

My top 5 bantamweights in order are : Zarate , Jofre , Ortiz , Brown , Olivares , I think Jofre would have beaten any bantamweight in history bar Zarate. Jofre had it all in the ring , everything.

Some of the fighters in your list were featherweights in their best days , but Jofre had a top record at that weight aswell , I give him 6 out of 10 , I think Zarate beats him , and Sanchez and Saddler {because of the size and weight} , and I just can't give him the win over Harada

dmt

10-23-2007, 08:37 AM

outside of Harada and possibly Zarate, all of them. I voted for 9

Jbuz

10-23-2007, 08:49 AM

I think he beats Zarate, but loses to Sanchez and Saddler. I voted 8. He is one of the best fighters ever, top 5-10 head-to-head P4P.

sweet_scientist

10-24-2007, 01:21 AM

At bantamweight a prime Jofre beats Zarate, Harada, McGovern, Olivares, Ortiz and Fenech imo.

At featherweight I think Saddler and Sanchez beat him but he'd beat the rest (of the guys listed).

When we are talking perfect fighters, Jofre should be one of the first fighters that come to mind. He did everything well, and in terms of straight punching, I don't think I've ever seen a straighter puncher in my life, and that's including Louis, Monzon, Arguello, Williams, Zarate, Tszyu, Lopez and others that were magnificent in that respect.

Senya13

10-24-2007, 02:50 AM

Five.

Panama Al Brown
Mauel Ortiz
Sandy Sadler
Jeff Fenech
Carlos Zarte