Should Shane try Vernon or Winky again?

[PanamaJack]

Or stay away from them for the rest of his career?

[FiveStoneFists]

If he is able to up the workrate, he may be able to defeat both but that is easier said then done. Both Forrest and Wright have a style that is all wrong for Mosley, but if he is aggressive he may take SDs. So why not, but only if and when he is confident he can beat them and apply the pressure and workrate necessary to do so.

[Chiko_Tech]

Nope now that Top Rank settle his deference, he will end up fighting Cotto that is more exiting that fighting those guys again.

[shelterr]

He would beat Vernon, but no chance at Winky.

[Motor City Sam]

He should stay away from them. He's probably not going to be fighting too much longer, and there are probably bigger, more lucrative fights to be made.

[IntentionalButt]

Well Winky has continued to gain hard mass and started to outgrow his middleweight body a while ago, whereas Shane is still a perfectly fit welterweight (slightly blown up in both Vargas fights). So the original problem there (two elite-talent guys, one with a size advantage) has not gone away, and the result would therefore probably be no different.

Vernon is ripe for a grudge match though, his skills have faded considerably more than Shane's, and without those skills his slight physical advantages lose most of their potency. I say he no longer has that number. :good

[brooklyn1550]

No...especially Winky

[IntentionalButt]

No...especially Winky

The Forrest that showed up against (i refuse to say 'beat') Quartey still beats the Shane that's been showing up lately?

[hopkinsfan07]

Winky is good of a boxer for shane

[hipnusol]

It'd be nice to see him take care of Vernon. I think he could at this point. But I'd stay away from Winky if I was him....

[PATSYS]

Or stay away from them for the rest of his career?

I think Shane should try Vernon again but he should stay away from Winky. He just couldn't beat Winky even on Winky's worst night.

[IntentionalButt]

really the only debate here is about forrest. and i think most believe that's a winnable fight for ssm now. it's ridiculous to even mention wink.

[IntentionalButt]

I alway's wanted to see Mosley fight Trinidad, it's a shame it never happened. If Shane would have decided not to fight Winky we would of had it, but hey that's life.

If Tito could even make 154 now, let alone welterweight, and if he weren't already rumored to be fighting either Roy or Oscar, tackling Shane would still be a terrible, terrible idea for him at this stage. Back whenever, who knows.

[jimmie]

Theres no point.

[Danny Ocean]

no hed lose

[IntentionalButt]

no hed lose

to both? back that up please :D (skip wink, since that goes w/o saying)