Name fighters who couldn't be successful...

[ApatheticLeader]

in the weightclass above which they operate. I don't mean fighters who are clearly overweight and shouldn't be in the weightclass they are in anyway. I mean fighters who have a style that means they would struggle in the weightclass above. Clearly, Ricky Hatton is a fighter who struggles as a welterweight. Another example might be Juan Diaz. Yes, he's podgy, but in any case his style may well mean he would struggle at 140lbs.

So people, let's name some one-division wonder boxers (and say why they couldn't be successful in the division above).

[kirk]

hatton... lol.

[BewareofDawg]

Judah. There is no way he would share the success he had at WW if he went to 154lbs :rofl

[Symphenyceo]

paul williams

[mightyd40]

paul williams
pw would dominate at 154

[Symphenyceo]

pw would dominate at 154


with that shit jab and piss poor defense no he wouldnt....spinks beats him and forrest might KTFO pw...paul doesnt have power at WW so at JMW it would be worst

[majinjohn]

Judah. There is no way he would share the success he had at WW if he went to 154lbs :rofl

Judah already moved up a division, he was a light welterweight.

[BewareofDawg]

Judah already moved up a division, he was a light welterweight.
so

[drunkenspaniard]

with that shit jab and piss poor defense no he wouldnt....spinks beats him and forrest might KTFO pw...paul doesnt have power at WW so at JMW it would be worst
His power might actually improve if he didn't have to come in so weight drained.

[Symphenyceo]

His power might actually improve if he didn't have to come in so weight drained.


it might and he should move up

[Haye]

David Haye?

Moving up to heavy. In fact 90% of cruisers moving up to heavyweight.