p4p top five for these catergories

[lbarrow]

do a top five for these three cats p4p fighters who are still fighting this is not ever its just current fighters


top 5 for power p4p
top 5 for chin p4p
top 5 for defence


mine:
power:
1. pavlik
2. haye
3. miranda
4. v. klitschko
5. valero

chin:
1. mccall
2. baldomir
3. tackie
4. pacquiao
5. mosely

defence:
1. mayweather
2. guzman
3. wright
4. calzaghe
5. abraham

[PH|LLA]

Guzman's defence is not that good. Abraham's defence is horrible. Hopkins still has the best defence in the sport.

[brooklyn1550]

POWER
1. David Haye
2. Kelly Pavlik
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. Kermit Cintron
5. Israel Vazquez

CHIN
1. Oliver McCall
2. David Tua
3. Librado Andrade
4. Carlos Baldomir
5. Shane Mosley

DEFENSE
1. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.
2. Joan Guzman
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Winky Wright

[TFFP]

Cintron has knocked out a load of bums. Big deal. When he knocks out somebody worth mentioning we'll talk

Power

1. Haye
2. Wlad
3. Pavlik
4. Pac

Chin

1. Baldomir
2. Calzaghe
3. Mosley
4. Tackie
5. Barrera

Defence

1. Mayweather
2. Calzaghe
3. Hopkins
4. Winky
5. Guzman

Defence was the easiest to do. There aren't many with great defences, so these stand out

Tackie was a great shout. Been in with some serious punchers, not least a prime Tszyu, and never been knocked out. Doesn't have a great defence either

[cableguy]

Power
1 Haye
2 Pavlik
3 Pac
4 Miranda
5 Maccarinelli

Chin
1 McCullough
2 Tua
3 Mccall
4 Calzaghe
5 Baldomir

Defence
1 Mayweather
2 Hopkins
3 Winky
4 Guzman
5 Calzaghe

[PhillyShell]

i don't see how winky can be anything but no. 2 defensively. and calazghe higher than him, really? cmon, that's just ridiculous.

[sues2nd]

Power:
1- Have to agree Pavlik
2- Pacman
3- Vazquez
4- Wlad
5- Cintro

Chin:
1- The one and only Oliver Mccall
2- Hopkins
3- Baldomir
4- Mosely
5- Ding

Defense:
1- Mayweather
2- Hopkins
3- Winky
4- Spinks (why does everyone forget this guy...I cant stand him either but...)
5- Calderon

[Healy]

Power
1- Pavlik
2- Haye
3- Pacman
4- Ponce De Leon
5- Cotto / Cintron

Chin
1- McCullough
2- McCall
3- Calzaghe
4- Toney
5- Tua

Defence
1- Mayweather
2- Winky
3- Hopkins
4- Toney
5- Calzaghe

[MJRJJ23]

Power:
1- Have to agree Pavlik
2- Pacman
3- Vazquez
4- Wlad
5- Cintro

Chin:
1- The one and only Oliver Mccall
2- Hopkins
3- Baldomir
4- Mosely
5- Ding

Defense:
1- Mayweather
2- Hopkins
3- Winky
4- Spinks (why does everyone forget this guy...I cant stand him either but...)
5- Calderon



I was thinking the same thing man when i was looking down the lists I couldn't believe nobody mentioned Spinks for defence, I dont like the guy either but there's no denying he has a good defence. Your lists look pretty solid overall also Except I would through Toney in the Chin category :good

[rydersonthestorm]

Haye
ding
Vasquez
wlad
pavlik

mccall
mccullough
tua
mosley
baldomir

mayweather
winky
hopkins
spinks
guzman

[Quik]

power:
1. Pavlik
2. Miranda
3. Ponce De Leon
4. Haye
5. Vasquez

chin:
1. Baldomir
2. Andrade
3. McCall
4. Pavlik
5.Vasquez

defence:
1. Mayweather
2. Guzman
3. Calderon
4. Mijares
5. Wright

[brooklyn1550]

I forgot about Ivan Calderon's defense. He'd be in my top 2-5.

[kg0208]

I see Ding Wilson mentioned for power once, but what about his chin?

[cardstars]

My lists:

Power:
1) Pavlik
2) Haye
3) Pacman
4) Wlad
5) Abraham (as of recently with his power training he is ridiculous)

Chin:
1) McCall (how can you go anyone else?)
2) Tua
3) Baldomir
4) Calzaghe
5) Andrade

Defense:
1) Mayweather
2) Spinks
3) Winky
4) Guzman
5) Calderon

Of course there are some guys that are deserving of being on these lists that are left off,,,,but its impossible to fit them all!