i truely believe robin reid beat joe calzaghe

[hide]

i scored the fight 115 to 113 for reid despite a harsh points deduction. what are peoples thoughts on this please.................

[majinjohn]

I had it a draw at the time, but I can see the argument for both guys winning, close fight.

[hide]

boxing news magerzine also had reid winning by 115 to 114

[scott is cool]

Never saw it. Anybody got a link to it?

[tays001]

i've see it ih ad joe winning by 115-113

[TFFP]

As it happens, I also had it 115-113 Joe

Reid said: "I can't argue with the decision. Joe was the better boxer on the night and I knew I could not catch him for speed."

[Vantage_West]

i dunno reid clearly did not dominate the rounds while joe did.

maybe ried looked to of won more rounds but joe did fight back a bit.

it's abit like hagler leonard (but of course ona totally different scale) you could say that leonard yes did win maybe more rounds but he didnt win the fight. you have to beat the champion and robin didnt do the job properly

[jc]

What rounds did u score for Ried excactly...?

Joes closest fight but stil an obvious win.

[Toopretty]

I never seen the fight, but Joe probably got his ass kicked as his fans are diluted dipshits.

[jc]

I never seen the fight, but Joe probably got his ass kicked as his fans are diluted dipshits.

yawn

#if u watch the fight u'll see the fans that night were v anti Joe. Watch th fight then you can pretend to kno what your on about.

[Vantage_West]

I never seen the fight, but Joe probably got his ass kicked as his fans are diluted dipshits.dilusional i think is the words...diluted means absolutly nothing in this context:think

WASTEMAN

[Bodysnatcher]

Funny thing is, in Joe's autobiography he talks about how anti-Calzaghe the Newcastle crowd was...but in his DVD, he gets interviewed before the (farcical) Pudwell fight and says `great to be back in Newcastle!`.

Calzaghe really doesn't like Reid...as another poster on here once pointed out, Joe despises losing so much, he can't forget that judge who gave the fight to Reid...

[Bodysnatcher]

Also worth pointing out that on Calzaghe's `best of` DVD, the Reid fight is completely absent while the Pudwell fight is shown in full.

Can't quite work that one out.

[Words]

I thought Reid won, infact I think I had it 7-4. The only thing is Reid didn't dominate the rounds clearly, there's at least 6 rounds that could go either way, but if I were the judge that night Reid would've got the nod.

Robin Reid is the ONLY man to have given Calzaghe such a close fight. Not even Kessler kept it as competetive as Reid did, Robin was always an underrated fighter even in his prime.

[Bodysnatcher]

Was the Reid fight the one where Joe broke his hand early on?

There's been so many of those I lose track of them...

[jc]

bad elbow.

[joe33]

Reid was a unlucky guy,what with this one which could have gone his way,and the sven ottke one in germany when the ref seemed to even stop him throwing a punch,he was a good fighter,sad to see him get wrecked by froch of whom i kind of like till he opens his big mouth.B y the way unless froch learns to not pull away with his damn hands down,hes gonna get knocked out,reid came very close in that fight before losing,and hes not a young man any more,his trainers must be tearing there hair out when he keeps doing that,hes asking for huge trouble.

[Rilz]

I never seen the fight, but Joe probably got his ass kicked as his fans are diluted dipshits.

wow you are a complete moron. I pity you

[Toopretty]

wow you are a complete moron. I pity you

I pity your sorry ass. My post is fucking spot on. Everything Calzaghe does, his avatar groupies multiply times 10. If YOU say it was a close fight edging towards Calzaghe, Id say Reid won 7 rounds in reality. I am looking for the fight now to see what ACTUALLY happend. Same jokers everytime. Pity these nuts as well.

[Toopretty]

dilusional i think is the words...diluted means absolutly nothing in this context:think

WASTEMANdi·lute play_w("D0225900") (d[Only registered and activated users can see links] d[Only registered and activated users can see links])tr.v. di·lut·ed, di·lut·ing, di·lutes 1. To make thinner or less concentrated by adding a liquid such as water.
2. To lessen the force, strength, purity, or brilliance of, especially by admixture.
3. To decrease the value of (shares of stock) by increasing the total number of shares.


I think I have his fans spot on. Next time, dont get owned so fucking bad.

[drvooh]

I think Joe won, but it was close.very close..it happens

[ro88o]

di·lute play_w("D0225900") (d[Only registered and activated users can see links] d[Only registered and activated users can see links])tr.v. di·lut·ed, di·lut·ing, di·lutes 1. To make thinner or less concentrated by adding a liquid such as water.
2. To lessen the force, strength, purity, or brilliance of, especially by admixture.
3. To decrease the value of (shares of stock) by increasing the total number of shares.


I think I have his fans spot on. Next time, dont get owned so fucking bad.

wheres dipshit in the dictionary and how can one be diluted?? i dont get it either....."diluted dipshits" :think lol

[FRKO]

Joe won. It wasn't easy, he also admitted he performed very badly after the fight and that people won't ever see a Joe Calzaghe like that again.

[FRKO]

Never saw it. Anybody got a link to it?
See PM's.

[FRKO]

and take that ridiculous wesley snipes avatar off he's a complete tool.
If you use Firefox, install the Adblock ([Only registered and activated users can see links]) extension, you can then block an annoying image permanently.

[Toopretty]

Ok bitch...diluted means to WATER DOWN....make thinner. I call you guys Diluted..watered down boxing fans.....Your judgment is diluted...watered down... As common slang terms suggest. "you are weak as water"

[Toopretty]

This thread shows how good Joe is. His only disputed win (not by many) was in a fight where he broke his hand after 2 or 3?? rounds. He is not only a great boxer, but also one of the greatest fighter. WInning against a dangerous opponen like Reid with one arm, amazing!

:lol::lol: The dude complains about breaking his hands EVERY fight. Thats the same excuse for not stopping lacy....etc. etc...fucking british excuses.

[FRKO]

Ok bitch...diluted means to WATER DOWN....make thinner. I call you guys Diluted..watered down boxing fans.....Your judgment is diluted...watered down... As common slang terms suggest. "you are weak as water"
I've heard "weak as piss" but not "weak as water". In fact, water is damn strong. Unless you consider a huge tsunami to be weak...


Regardless, Joe Calzaghe won against Reid. It doesn't take a genius to work this out if you watch the fight. Joe did get caught a lot, but he wasn't exactly phased by the right hand that kept catching him. Great chin.

[ro88o]

Ok bitch...diluted means to WATER DOWN....make thinner. I call you guys Diluted..watered down boxing fans.....Your judgment is diluted...watered down... As common slang terms suggest. "you are weak as water"

watered down?? weak as water?? i still dont get it...

diluted dipshits...lol :good

[FRKO]

Was it supposed to be "deluded dipshits"?

[Still~style]

Ok bitch...diluted means to WATER DOWN....make thinner. I call you guys Diluted..watered down boxing fans.....Your judgment is diluted...watered down... As common slang terms suggest. "you are weak as water"

lol you can't talk your way out of this one. doesn't make much sense. "weak as water" wtf. a cubic metre of water weghs a ton.

[Toopretty]

I am talking slang.......it aint supposed to make sense...If I say, "that *****s is weak as water" Or he is a watered down motherfucker. That makes perfect sense. I guess you need to go to the urban dictionary.

[Toopretty]

I am talking slang.......it aint supposed to make sense...If I say, "that *****s is weak as water" Or he is a watered down motherfucker. That makes perfect sense. I guess you need to go to the urban dictionary.

[Still~style]

I am talking slang.......it aint supposed to make sense...If I say, "that *****s is weak as water" Or he is a watered down motherfucker. That makes perfect sense. I guess you need to go to the urban dictionary.

sure thing all-star.

[Vantage_West]

di·lute play_w("D0225900") (d[Only registered and activated users can see links] d[Only registered and activated users can see links])tr.v. di·lut·ed, di·lut·ing, di·lutes 1. To make thinner or less concentrated by adding a liquid such as water.
2. To lessen the force, strength, purity, or brilliance of, especially by admixture.
3. To decrease the value of (shares of stock) by increasing the total number of shares.


I think I have his fans spot on. Next time, dont get owned so fucking bad. diluted....what:huh!!!! that doesnt explain anything.

saying diluted means what?

so diluted dipshits means individuals who are being diluted:think ....thats what duzna make sense

just adding a dictionary mark doenst help your course sir:good

[China_hand_Joe]

Calzaghe cruised the first 4, then Reid had a point deducted.

Reid would have need almost all of the remaining rounds to win. These scores 2 or 3 points in Reid favour are insanity.

It was close but you cannot argue against a Calzaghe win.

[sambob]

dilusional i think is the words...diluted means absolutly nothing in this context:think

WASTEMAN

No, the word would be DELUDED. Dilusional doesn't mean anything at all that I know of. Or delusional depending on the use.

[41fever]

I had it for REID too...Reid kept on landing that hard right hand...

[Vantage_West]

No, the word would be DELUDED. Dilusional doesn't mean anything at all that I know of. Or delusional depending on the use.shut up spamblob i cant spell but i do know what i mean...spelt wrong or not it doesnt matter he does not mean diluted:D

[PH|LLA]

I thought Reid won, infact I think I had it 7-4. The only thing is Reid didn't dominate the rounds clearly, there's at least 6 rounds that could go either way, but if I were the judge that night Reid would've got the nod.

Robin Reid is the ONLY man to have given Calzaghe such a close fight. Not even Kessler kept it as competetive as Reid did, Robin was always an underrated fighter even in his prime.
Calzaghe is known to be quite inconsistant and put on one of his best performances against Kessler. I haven't seen the Reid fight but its quite likely that the Calzaghe that fought Kessler was better on that night.

[achillesthegreat]

Joe won and while being injured, I believe a broken hand and bad elbow.

Reid was awkward but not putting in the necessary work. I think I had Calzaghe about 7-4-1 to 8-4.

[Ghoulie]

a draw would have been fairer - personally thought Reid just shaded it

What about the Reid / Ottke farce of a fight. Robin should have been allowed to smakc the ref one and then be allowed to fight without his interference.

Pity Calzaghe didn't fight Ottke - reckon he would have beaten him.

[PrideOfWales]

Reid had his moments in this fight but I can't remember thinking he'd done enough to win. Calzaghe won by a close margin.

[Beatboxer]

A close but clear win to Calzaghe is the consensus.

Reid admitted he lost. Why would others question it?

Agenda against Joe? I think so.

Soon the old bastard lovers will flee this site in a mass exodus not dissimilar to the Kesslerites following the events of November 3rd.

[bongsbomber]

:lol::lol: The dude complains about breaking his hands EVERY fight. Thats the same excuse for not stopping lacy....etc. etc...fucking british excuses.

Are you fucking serious or are you Dame Edna Everage in disguise

[mattress]

I am talking slang.......it aint supposed to make sense...If I say, "that *****s is weak as water" Or he is a watered down motherfucker. That makes perfect sense. I guess you need to go to the urban dictionary.

What a grade-A twat!

[Toopretty]

i dunno reid clearly did not dominate the rounds while joe did.

maybe ried looked to of won more rounds but joe did fight back a bit.

it's abit like hagler leonard (but of course ona totally different scale) you could say that leonard yes did win maybe more rounds but he didnt win the fight. you have to beat the champion and robin didnt do the job properly
Off topic, your signature proves my point that Shane cant turn his punches properly.

[Toopretty]

What a grade-A twat!

Grade D meat. That shit they feed dogs.

[Decebal]

No. I watched the fight giving Reid the benefit of the doubt as much as I could, and by any scenario, Joe wins it by at least 1, in my view.

[teke]

Pity Calzaghe didn't fight Ottke - reckon he would have beaten him.I think Joe would have beaten him with ease.

[bratwurzt]

It was close but on another note, Reid was robbed against Ottke for sure.

[MasterCalzaghe]

An injured Joe closely beats a healthy Reid.

What would a healthy Joe do?

[Shake]

di·lute play_w("D0225900") (d[Only registered and activated users can see links] d[Only registered and activated users can see links])tr.v. di·lut·ed, di·lut·ing, di·lutes 1. To make thinner or less concentrated by adding a liquid such as water.
2. To lessen the force, strength, purity, or brilliance of, especially by admixture.
3. To decrease the value of (shares of stock) by increasing the total number of shares.


I think I have his fans spot on. Next time, dont get owned so fucking bad.

You meant deluded, admit it.

[Ghoulie]

don't get me wrong - Joe is a very very good boxer - I rate him exceedingly highly - ok he has his off fights - but against Lacy - what a boxing lesson ! Kessler too - he did a good job on him. Lets hope Joe does go out at the top as he's hinted

[Smith]

It was one of them fights where neither fighter deserved to lose.

[Beatboxer]

Its similar to the Lewis-Mercer fight in that it was close, closer than most of the all time greats fighters usually are(that is calzaghe and lewis) but any objective fan can see that it was a close but clear victory!

JC won....it would have been a bad decision otherwise as it would have been if Mercer had got the nod against Lewis

[Boro chris]

What a grade-A twat!

:D Then put the guy on ignore! Unless of course you find him amusing!

[mstar]

in joes autobiography joe said he was at his worse in that fight interms of preparation/things on his mind in his personal life