Trinidad vs. Toney @ 160. At their best, who wins?

[younghov2k4]

I was watching some old Trinidad fights last night on youtube and I couldn't help but think of some fantasy matchups. They are both in my top 5 for all time favorite so I'm not sure who I would pick but I might lean for Toney.

What do you all think? How would this play out to you?

Toney's defense and counter punching or Tito's aggression and power shots?

[Asterion]

Toney schools the fuck out of him.

[BigReg]

Toney, easily. Trinidad was a puncher, he won't beat a superior boxer in his prime. The only two boxers Trinidad faced at 160 completely dominated him. De La Hoya even outboxed his ass(DLH would've won had he fought down the stretch). This is a terrible matchup for Tito. My prediciton, one sided beat down in favor of Toney.

[kg0208]

Come on....Trinidad doesn't even have a punchers chance in this one, much less a chance in a straight up match up.

[Lance_Uppercut]

Toney would stop him in about 6 rounds IMHO.

[fightking12]

Toney would probably ko him in the 8 round

[joe the great]

Both at their best I like Toney.

[Lostmykeys]

Was this guys serious with this matchup:?

[brooklyn1550]

Toney by wide UD or late stoppage

[Brighton bomber]

Toney would win a wide decision or even stop him late. Toney would be much bigger and Tito's greatest strength, his punching power wouldn't be enough to hurt Toney.

[C Money]

Toney easily. Btw? Trinidad's best is at 47 so it's a rather poor comparison.

[digiram]

Toney of course. No disrespect to Tito though. He was a badass mofo at 147.

[carras]

Toney is too damn big for tito..

[*BOX_FAN*]

Trinidad has no chance. Toney by wide UD.

[See Me Flow]

Toney by UD or even late TKO.

[PBF P4P #1]

What if they fight now at Heavyweight? :)

Winner gets Vargas.

[theDUD3]

even if we remove Toney's 133t skills from the equation his iron-chin would withstand some of Tito's best punches.

toney-skills-chin > tito-power

[surreal deal]

Trinidad has no chance. Toney by wide UD.
spot on,though maybe stoppage.:good

[surreal deal]

Was this guys serious with this matchup:?
some fights you see as one-sided others see as competitive,eg lewis-tyson.

[joito3]

this is like asking who would win between DLH & Hagler LMAO !!!!

[King Dan]

Toney wins every round against Tito, except for maybe one where he gets put on his butt, but then gets up and continues schooling Tito.

Toney 11 rounds to 1.

[boy-wonder]

even though he took same peters best shots, i am not sure if he could deal with tito's power ahhahhahahahaha

[Thread Stealer]

Neither Toney nor Trinidad were at their best @ 160.

Toney wins provided he's not in bad shape (by his standards).

[cuzzinelias]

shooo cuz,

This match is so El-Haiq Aziz.

bonecrunching power, check
hookah pipe iron lung stamina, check
supertight linebeard, check

Signs all point to a brutal knockout at the hands of Trinidad, Toney's too fat, slow & stupid

[surreal deal]

this is like asking who would win between DLH & Hagler LMAO !!!!
come on!Marvin would have some chance.

[VX.Nefarious]

you fucking with me?

Toney by KO

[christo]

Trinidad was no middleweight and hopkins and winky showed it. Toney
was a big middle with mad skills and a cast iron chin. Toney would cause
felix to have reoccuring nightmares 'bout the beating he received.

[Mr. HU]

Toney easily. Btw? Trinidad's best is at 47 so it's a rather poor comparison.

:deal

[TBomb 25]

I see this bout looking like Toney-Holyfield with Toney being even faster,this would be a brutal beatdown!

[vargasfan1985]

Is this really a topic?

[Clinton]

Toney schools the fuck out of him.
Yup

[Clinton]

What if they fight now at Heavyweight? :)

Winner gets Vargas.
OOOOOOOHHHHHH:lol::lol::good

[jaysuperman27]

Toney any day

[bernie4366]

JT would put a horrible beating on him, clowning the whole way.

[RobertV77]

I was watching some old Trinidad fights last night on youtube and I couldn't help but think of some fantasy matchups. They are both in my top 5 for all time favorite so I'm not sure who I would pick but I might lean for Toney.

What do you all think? How would this play out to you?

Toney's defense and counter punching or Tito's aggression and power shots?


The outcome should not be in question.

[MrPR]

Ill be rooting for Trinidad,But he would get dismantled by Toney at Middleweight

This fight would probably end in a stoppage win for Toney

[iceman71]

I was watching some old Trinidad fights last night on youtube and I couldn't help but think of some fantasy matchups. They are both in my top 5 for all time favorite so I'm not sure who I would pick but I might lean for Toney.

What do you all think? How would this play out to you?

Toney's defense and counter punching or Tito's aggression and power shots?

heres the difference...i watched trinidads fights on showtime LIVE back when he destroyed maurice blocker on showtimeand as he progressed...as a welterweight.... you watched them on youtube....meaning, you have no idea that trinidad is not a real middleweight, having only a handfull of fights at that weight and where all his losses have come at....where as toney fought 40 plus fights at 160. toney beats his ass ten times worse than what hopkins did.....

[Xplosive]

One sided ass whuppin in favor of Toney.

[ChrisKim47]

Toney easily. Reason? Trinidad doesn't box he punches. More clearly his head is always in the same place. He would get tagged all night. But who knows what would happen to Toney if he got hit with dem loaded gloves Trinidad got sponsored.

[Hatesrats]

Toney by K.O.
(Trinidad had no reason to fight beyond 147lbs)

[Boxed Ears]

I don't see Toney stopping Tito. But I do see him technically dismantling him to a wide decision victory.

[Thread Stealer]

Toney by K.O.
(Trinidad had no reason to fight beyond 147lbs)

He had weight problems at 147, he only stayed there after 97' for the big fights with Whitaker and DLH.

154 was a good weight for him.

[Xplosive]

I don't see Toney stopping Tito. But I do see him technically dismantling him to a wide decision victory.

Toney at 160 was a bigger puncher then Hopkins. Tito aint seein the distance.

[Xplosive]

Toney by K.O.
(Trinidad had no reason to fight beyond 147lbs)

Tito draining himself for years to make 147 was a pretty good reason to leave.

[Farmboxer]

Toney.

[puertorricane]

tito by KO...

:hat

[Zopilote]

Tito gets embarrassed worse than he did against B-Hop and Winky. Only a stupid biased boricua would vote for Tito.

[bigtime-skills]

Tito is my DAWG, but he has NO chance with james Toney.....

Tito was really a 147-154lb fighter fighting a guy with one of the BEST chins ever with ridiculous boxing skills.....

TKO around Round 5

[The Phenom]

Toney by decision.

[See Me Flow]

Toney.

[Ring Master]

perfect style match up for Toney