PDA

View Full Version : Malignaggi's Progress(Paul vs Floyd)


Leeroy
07-06-2007, 01:22 AM
Malignaggi blasted on the scene 2 years ago;an unknown prospect by most hard-core boxing fans,but well known in the Brooklyn circle.

When Paul Malignaggi first stepped into the public spot-light,the majority of fight fans,including myself,thought he was an over-hyped boxer,trying to make a name for himself with his jaw - his boxing ability was evident from day one;but how far that boxing ability could take him was anyone's guess(Without fighting a game opponent).

That soon changed when he fought Cotto.

Stepping up and facing Cotto,that early in his career already cemented the fact he's not afraid of REAL competition....In my opinion,Malignaggi,in his supreme arrogance,or CONFIDENCE if you will;wanted badly to prove his skills to the world/boxing public.

Most people thought Paulie was enroute to an early night,via TKO/KO - that wasn't the case. He fought valiantly,for most of the fight with one hand,a swollen face and a broken cheek-bone - all attributes of a real fighting gentlemen. Paul won 5 rounds according to most boxing fans,myself included;hardly a performance by an over-hyped shit-talker.

Given all of this,I think Malignaggi needed badly a loss on his record,to better prepare him for the future crown of the 140 pound division....The loss on behalf of Cotto has done wonders for his boxing-mentality,his reality,and more importantly,has grounded him.

He came back months later and derailed a game opponent in N'dou. He commpletely dominated,out-classed,and boxed N'dou via a 12 round UD.

Seeing as how Malignaggi is far from his respective fighting-prime,and with 2 more big fights - possibly Hatton/Witter......How do you see him matching up against Floyd Mayweather(Given the fact Mayweather beats Hatton,if they fight)?

Stylistically? Paulie has speed to boot,much like Mayweather. I would venture and take a guess;Malignaggi has better foot-work,and the better jab,while mayweather encompasses him in every other conceivable catagory.

How would you rate Malignaggi's progress thus far,and likewise,judge a possible Floyd Mayweather vs Paul Malignaggi square-off?

younghov2k4
07-06-2007, 01:27 AM
Mayweather def wouldn't fight Paul before Cotto and if Floyd beats Cotto, why would he want to fight Malignaggi?

i don't see that fight being anywhere close to happening within the next year and a half at least.

Farmboxer
07-06-2007, 01:30 AM
Malignaggi could beat Mayweather, a couple more fights and I will be rather sure of it.

Leeroy
07-06-2007, 01:32 AM
Wouldn;t be happening anytime soon. Mayweather would school him as is though. Paulie is fast, but not that fast. Mayweather is more accurate, better on the inside, and is just overall much better. I think he at least wins a Wide UD.

hoNlowQwNL0

bigtime9
07-06-2007, 02:18 AM
get the fuck outta here with that paulie shit. I mean when paulie wins 5 titles in five different weight classes then get back to me:blood

Leeroy
07-06-2007, 02:20 AM
get the fuck outta here with that paulie shit. I mean when paulie wins 5 titles in five different weight classes then get back to me:blood

So you're denying his skills?

PBF P4P #1
07-06-2007, 02:23 AM
I guess nobody heard Paulie saying on Friday Night Fights (During Ding/Nwodo) that he would school Hatton, but not as bad as Mayweather because nobody (including himself which he stated) is on Mayweather's level.

bigtime9
07-06-2007, 02:26 AM
So you're denying his skills?

what skills are you babbling about. go watch a floyd fight at 140 and a paulie fight AT 140 and then get back to me about "skill" paulie would get beat to death by floyd, they are not even on the same level:nono

bigtime9
07-06-2007, 02:27 AM
Don't listen to fagtime9, he is THE joke of ESB.

that's not what your mom said last night:lol:

bigtime9
07-06-2007, 02:41 AM
You sure owned me!

it's not hard mutt boy, you're just like a geico caveman all brow and no braun:scaredas:

WhataRock
07-06-2007, 02:42 AM
He fights like but Floyd does it a lot better and in every field.

I like the kid, he isnt as negative as PBF but I think thats cause he needs to be because he doesnt quite have the defensive skills or reflexes to do what Floyd does.

Its like a 94 Camaro dragging a 06 Camaro, same thing but one is better.

Leeroy
07-06-2007, 03:00 AM
what skills are you babbling about. go watch a floyd fight at 140 and a paulie fight AT 140 and then get back to me about "skill" paulie would get beat to death by floyd, they are not even on the same level:nono

What skills am I talking about? You must've not seen Paul fight before,because anyone claiming he doesn't have boxing skill sure as fuck doesn't know anything about boxing....

I've seen Mayweather fight over 30 times - did I deny his skills? No. doing so would implicate I'm retarted......Like you.:thumbsup

And you haven't read my post either - I said Floyd is better in every other conceivable boxing category.

Leeroy
07-06-2007, 03:03 AM
Ohoooooooooooo good one! You sure owned me! Here's a little retaliation, in case Leeroy hasn't seen your pic

hurhurhurhurhurhur!!!!

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

:lol::lol:

See Me Flow
07-06-2007, 04:31 AM
So you're denying his skills?

Yes Maliganaggi has skills...half the skills of PBF. PBF over Malignaggi by UD or late TKO.

myk
07-06-2007, 04:38 AM
Malignaggi is a very talented boxer. I was surprised he lasted that long with Cotto even if his face was unrecognizable after the fight. I think Floyd would school him though. I want to see him against Casa for now

achillesthegreat
07-06-2007, 07:22 AM
There progress is not comparable. Floyd burst onto the scene, got 17 fights under his belt quick then fought the linear champ at 130. Two months later he blew out another top 5 130, then hes racking up defence after defence and dominating all in sight. Then he reiterates his greatness by raping Corrales.

Malignaggis progress doesn't compare.

Malignaggi will be awkward but Floyd will walk him down like he did Zab, Mitchell, Corley etc

Rock0052
07-07-2007, 02:04 AM
The quickest route for Paulie to take the next step in his career is to try and unify 140, then parlay that into a big fight with Hatton/PBF/Cotto. I don't know if the alphabet boys will have any of it, or if Paulie's got that on his agenda or not, though.

huki
07-07-2007, 04:10 AM
Paulie would be the first to admit that he would get beaten by Floyd. He always talks about how great PBF is in interviews and he even said that he thinks Floyd would beat SRR at welter.

pit
07-07-2007, 10:04 AM
hoNlowQwNL0


There nothing in this sparing that leads me to believe that Paul is on floyd level. he sparing a guys thats standing straight up and not bending at the waist at all .. You saw what floyd did to Zab who's hand speed is faster then paul's .. In short you need more then speed when competing on the upper levels of boxing and Paul is not there yet.

If floyd fought Paul right now Floyd would be highly criticized, that how far outta range Paul is right now.