Tom Sharkey vs. Marvin Hart

[Luigi1985]

Who wins and why?

[janitor]

The fans win.

It could be a classic.

It is hard to be sure which of these two swarmers was better but when Hart was champion he wasnt thought to be in Sharkeys league.

[mattdonnellon]

Hart won well in one of his encounters with a still reasonably good Ruhlin but then again there was no Bill Hanrahan in Tom's career! A pick 'em fight if ever there was one and I pick ........................................................Hart. Janitor is correct IMO the fans would be the big winners.

[Mendoza]

The fans win.

It could be a classic.

It is hard to be sure which of these two swarmers was better but when Hart was champion he wasnt thought to be in Sharkeys league.

Both guys had a lot of heart and Stamina.

Sharkey had a more dynamic track you down approach, probably hit harder and took a better punch.

IMO, Shakrey in his prime was better than Hart in his.

[Langford]

would be a great fight, both fighters coming in on the attack. I would take a pre-Jeffries II Sharkey over the fighting Kentuckian, but would be very excited before the fight, knowing that it would be a great styles match.

I pick Sharkey because I do believe him to be the more durable of the two opponents and his rough, not by the book tactics, could possibly throw Hart off of his game.

[mattdonnellon]

Hart was a dirty so-and -so too and possibly a better boxer,intriguing.