Who's better the Judah that fought Floyd or the Judah that fought Cotto?

[fitzgeraldz]

We all can agree that both Judah's lost ... the Judah that lost to Cotto was beaten very bad ... he was also off for 400 + days and had been beaten pretty bad by PBF.

You can say the same thing about PBF ... he lost to Baldomir by SD and hurt Judah very bad.

[K0NPHL1C7]

Well, Judah in the early fight against Cotto looked pretty good, but he had to overcome the low-blows by Miguel.

[thewoo]

I'd say they both fought a pretty similar version of Judah. He was equally as in shape and focused for both of them and was able to trouble both guys early.

[196osh]

I would say Judah that fought Floyd and Cotto pretty much the same level.

[fitzgeraldz]

I don't know what fight you guys seen ... but Judah shouldnt have been in there past the 7th against Cotto. Yeah he rocked Cotto early on but that can be contributed to Cotto being a slow starter. I gave Judah a couple of rounds against Cotto. Past the 4th ... he was just getting beat down.

[Asterion]

Clearly, the Judah that fought Mayweather was slightly better. He had a one-year inactivity period after that fight.

[fitzgeraldz]

Its hard to say ... I seen Judah fighting on instinct more against Cotto - but it was clear that he had worked hard in preparation for his fight against PBF.

I'm not saying that Judah was better fighting PBF - but he was more focused.

[Pimp C]

Clearly, the Judah that fought Mayweather was slightly better. He had a one-year inactivity period after that fight.
I agree.

[joito3]

according to judah himself he was in better shape and more focused for the cotto fight

[Pimp C]

according to judah himself he was in better shape and more focused for the cotto fight
He says that before every big fight. He's saying it now for the Mosley fight.:deal

[fitzgeraldz]

good shit pimp c

[BewareofDawg]

This is an impossible question to answer. He was in shape and highly motivated for both. They both beat a prime Judah.

[julio]

Like you said on both cases he lost,but he definitely had a better performance against Cotto simply because he was able to keep his cool and composure in check pretty much throughout the fight unlike the Mayweather fiasco,I was dissapointed though that he didn"t use the left hand more often,every time he hit Cotto with it he rocked him but still at the end I was not expecting a different outcome,he was never the same fighter after Kostya Tzyu knocked him out,even though his good performance against Cory Spinks in the rematch.

[fitzgeraldz]

I think Cotto v Judah wasn't tacticle and it was more of an all out brawl ... Cotto getting the better of Judah for the majority of the fight.

The PBF fight was tacticle and more of a chess match ... he has history w/ Floyd and really was aiming at beating PBF at his own game.

The fight w/ Cotto - he was at home in NY and was talking big shit - so he had to prove that he was tougher than Cotto rather than be a better boxer.

[Richel Hersisia]

i agree with that inboth fights he was on his best. possible his two best performance with spinks II.

He gave them both trouble early on. but both seemed to be the better as the fight went on

[Pimp C]

good shit pimp c
:good

[superchile]

theres only one judha and hes inconsistent and inmature get over it

[Samurai]

Equal I think

[thewoo]

I don't know what fight you guys seen ... but Judah shouldnt have been in there past the 7th against Cotto. Yeah he rocked Cotto early on but that can be contributed to Cotto being a slow starter. I gave Judah a couple of rounds against Cotto. Past the 4th ... he was just getting beat down.

I think that had more to do with the beatdown that Cotto was putting on him than his shape going into the fight. Against Floyd he was able to compete a little longer cause Floyd was not hurting him as much.