Marvin Hagler v Jack Dempsey, Tiger Flowers, Tommy Gibbons & Tommy Ryan

[McGrain]

How do you think Hagler would go with these old school middleweights?

[teeto]

How do you think Hopkins would go with these old school middleweights?
McGrain , are we talking Hopkins, or Hagler? In the title you put Hagler, but then in your post you said Hopkins

[McGrain]

Thanks Teeto we are talking about Hagler, my mistake.

[Holmes' Jab]

I'd think he'd probably beat them all, Hopkins too. None would be easy, though. I think Ryan might given him the toughest assignment from those you listed.

[teeto]

Thanks Teeto we are talking about Hagler, my mistake.
Its alright, i have him above them all as a ATG MW, but h2h? It might sound a bit over the top saying he would beat them all, as they were great MWs, but i think Hagler might actually win all of them, certainly had the mindset to deal with the rougher, tougher era imo. In fairness though, id be a bit more well equipped to comment on a placement of these guys on a MW list of ATGs, dont know a great deal about them stylistically. I still pick Hagler though!!!