Better quality of opposition: Cotto or Margarito?

[DaveTheWave]

Who has the better resume, and who has fought a higher level of opposition? The obvious answer is Cotto to me, am I nuts?

[whit]

Cotto

[thewoo]

I'd say Judah, Mosley and Quintana put Cotto over the top. Up until that point they were about even

[Rumsfeld]

I'd say Judah, Mosley and Quintana put Cotto over the top. Up until that point they were about even

:nod

[Asterion]

This question is ridiculous.

Cotto by far. Antonio Margarito's resume sucks: his best wins are over a guy that built his reputation beating Mark fuckin Suarez. :rofl

[1lehudson]

Who has the better resume, and who has fought a higher level of opposition? The obvious answer is Cotto to me, am I nuts?Is this a serious question??? Margo fought Williams and lost, Santos and lost, and a bunch of scrubs.

[Montero]

Cotto. But to say that Margarito's resume "sucks" is a pretty ignorant statement. Cotto started fighting as a pro when he was a teenager with no amateur experience - many of his early loses were "growing pains" that Cotto had the benefit of getting in the amatuers. So in several ways, Cotto's resume may be "better", but Margarito's has been "tougher" - as in a harder road to travel down...

Make sense?

[Relentless]

Is this a serious question??? Margo fought Williams and lost, Santos and lost, and a bunch of scrubs.

but he would still kick you and your cock lovin' fathers ass on the same minute.

[Asterion]

Cotto. But to say that Margarito's resume "sucks" is a pretty ignorant statement. Cotto started fighting as a pro when he was a teenager with no amateur experience - many of his early loses were "growing pains" that Cotto had the benefit of getting in the amatuers. So in several ways, Cotto's resume may be "better", but Margarito's has been "tougher" - as in a harder road to travel down...

Make sense?


I am saying that Margarito's resume sucks not because of his loses, but because his best wins: Kermit Cintron.

[1lehudson]

but he would still kick you and your cock lovin' fathers ass on the same minute.I would bet not, they have weights for a reason. I could cut off both legs and still out weight Margo by 50 pounds, not to mention Im pretty nice with my hands:bbb

[Relentless]

combined opponents records of cotto hatton and margo.

Cotto
747-155-18 (6 undefeated)

Hatton
940-383-65 (3 undefeated)

Margarito
828-208-24 (6 undefeated)

[Relentless]

I would bet not, they have weights for a reason. I could cut off both legs and still out weight Margo by 50 pounds, not to mention Im pretty nice with my hands:bbb

you would outweigh me by 50 pounds too but i'd still molest you like you were my step son.

[fitzgeraldz]

Cotto

[Relentless]

Cotto

hows your ass?:hi:

[Samurai]

Cotto, no question

[Ambition_Def]

Cotto but don't play like Margo has had it easy. He's had one of the toughest roads as a pro.

Cotto on the other hand has been nurtured and it makes obvious sense that his record and resume of wins would be better.

Besides what difference does it make. If best wins and resumes meant something then Glen Johnson wouldn't have come close to controversy against Chad Dawson.

[Scar]

Cotto.