Unusual scorecard...

[Miles5149]

I was on boxrec earlier just browsing around on some fighters and I came across this scorecard for a fighter named Kevin Boswell...

[Only registered and activated users can see links]

Date - 2007-04-21
Opponent - Tim Johnson 1-0-0
Location - National Guard Armory, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
Outcome - W UD 4 Rounds
Referee: Shawn Clark
Score - | judge: Bill Nealon 40-34 | judge: Dave Greer 40-34 | judge: Dewey LaRosa 35-39 ~

I was just wondering how a fight could possible be scored that way. Considering if it was 40-34 in a 4 rounder, that would either mean a 2 knockdowns or a deduction and/or a knockdown wouldn't it? I'm sorry if I'm missing something but this just baffled me.

[MagicManPaulie]

that third judge must be blind or visually impaired.. hahah.. i cant explain it either bro

[Beebs]

10-8,
10-8,
10-9 (there was a KD but the loser dominate the round otherwise, or all the other judges gave a non KD round 10-8 but he didnt),
9-10

[GazOC]

Theres no mystery there really, I'd guess the last judge just got reported the for wrong opponent.

[Miles5149]

10-8,
10-8,
10-9 (there was a KD but the loser dominate the round otherwise, or all the other judges gave a non KD round 10-8 but he didnt),
9-10

my point was 2 judges have it 40-34 for one guy and 39-35 for the other. Unless boxrec just put the score the opposite way for whatever reason because it does say UD, but I don't know. Oh well either way it's not exactly for the undisputed title

[Beebs]

my point was 2 judges have it 40-34 for one guy and 39-35 for the other. Unless boxrec just put the score the opposite way for whatever reason because it does say UD, but I don't know. Oh well either way it's not exactly for the undisputed title

Misread it.

Thats fucked up

[theunderdog]

same as the scorecards for the last mijares fight. the judge probably mistook one fighter for the other

[theunderdog]

Russell Mora | judge: Chris Wilson 115-113 | judge: Doug Tucker 108-120 | judge: Adalaide Byrd 117-111 ~

can't explain this shit either

[GazOC]

Sometimes (mosttimes!!) they are just typos or one judge mistaking the fighters.