PDA

View Full Version : Who do you think are Britain's greatest 5 ever heavyweights?


JonOli
07-10-2008, 07:18 PM
Who do you think, in order, are Britain's top 5 greatest ever heavyweights?


This may be a pretty easy one to pick; I haven't really though about it.


Just to throw around names....here's a random list lifted from somewere....

Tommy Farr: A former coal miner from Wales, Farr was among the most courageous heavyweights of his era. He beat the likes of Tommy Loughran, Bob Olin and former heavyweight king Max Baer. But when he challenged reigning champ Joe Louis on August 30, 1937, courage only took him so far. He lost a unanimous decision. Louis made 25 defenses of the heavyweight crown, knocking out 22 of his challengers. Only Farr, Arturo Godoy and Jersey Joe Walcott lasted the distance with Louis.
Don Cockell: A blacksmith by trade, Cockell began boxing in 1946. He beat an aging Farr en route to winning the British and Commonwealth crowns and later defeated American contender Roland LaStarza. He challenged heavyweight champ Rocky Marciano on May 16, 1955 at Kezar Stadium in San Francisco. Marciano swarmed over his foe but the British contender managed to withstand the attack until the eighth round. Cockell was dropped in the 8th and twice in the 9th but arose from each knockdown. However, the referee had seen enough and stopped the contest after the third knockdown. Marciano said after the fight, "He's got a lot of guts. I don't think I ever hit anyone else any more often or harder."
Henry Cooper: Known as "Our 'Enery." The most beloved heavyweight in British history, Cooper held the British, Commonwealth and European heavyweight crowns. However, Cooper was best known for his two bouts with Muhammad Ali. The first came in 1963 at Wembley Stadium and Cooper managed to floor the future champ with a left hook in Round 4. The bout would end a round later with Cooper bleeding profusely from above the left eye. The fight has taken on a mythical status because it was revealed later that Ali's cornerman Angelo Dundee bought his charge more time between rounds after the knockdown by splitting the American's glove. Three years later, Cooper challenged Ali with the heavyweight title on the line and was again stopped on cuts, this time in Round 6.
Brian London: He lost a pair of bouts to Cooper and also lost in a pair of heavyweight title fights. London was knocked out by champion Floyd Patterson in the 11th round of a 1959 bout and was stopped by Ali in three rounds in 1966.
Joe Bugner: He was born in Hungary but launched his pro career in London in 1967. Fought out of England until his retirement from boxing. Defeated Henry Cooper in 1971 to win British, Commonwealth and European heavyweight titles. He beat notable American heavyweights such as Chuck Wepner, Mac Foster and Jimmy Ellis. At 6-5, he was more boxer than puncher. In 1973, he lost consecutive 12-round fights to Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier. Bugner challenged Ali for the world heavyweight title on July 1. 1975 in Kuala Lampur and lost a 15-round decision. Made a comeback to boxing and in 1998, at the age of 48, he defeated former WBA champ Bonecrusher Smith, who was 45.
Richard Dunn: A southpaw born in Halifax, England, Dunn held the British and Commonwealth heavyweight crowns in 1975. He challenged Muhammad Ali for the heavyweight crown on May 24, 1976 in Munich and was stopped in five rounds.
Frank Bruno: He had posted wins over Gerrie Coetzee, Carl "The Truth" Williams and James "Quick" Tillis, but couldn't win the big one until the ordinary Oliver McCall became champ. Bruno decisioned McCall for the WBC heavyweight title in 1995. Bruno, who had above average power, failed to win the heavyweight title from Tim Witherspoon in 1986, Mike Tyson in 1989 and Lennox Lewis in 1993. After racing to a fast start, Bruno was knocked out in each of those title challenges. In 1996 Bruno would meet Tyson again. This time Bruno held the WBC belt while Tyson was challenger. The result, however, was the same. Tyson stopped Bruno in the third round.
Lennox Lewis: He won a gold medal for Canada in the 1988 Olympics but returned to England, his place of birth, to launch his pro career. Initially, British boxing fans didn't warm to Lewis because he was considered a Canadian (He moved to Canada from London when he was 12). That changed when he knocked out Razor Ruddock in two rounds at London's Earls Court in 1992 and was subsequently awarded the WBC title. American rival and undisputed champ Riddick Bowe vacated the WBC belt rather than meet Lewis in a mandatory match. Thus, Lewis became England's first heavyweight king since Bob Fitzsimmons in 1899. He lost the belt when Oliver McCall upset him via second-round knockout in 1994. He later regained the WBC crown with a TKO over McCall. Then in a bid to unify the heavyweight crown, Lewis met WBA/IBF champ Evander Holyfield in March of 1999 at Madison Square Garden. The bout, which many thought that Lewis had clearly won, was declared a draw. They met in rematch later in '99 and this time Lewis left no doubts, winning a unanimous decision and the undisputed heavyweight title. Since that meeting, he lost the title to Hasim Rahman and then regained it with a knockout, much the way he did with McCall. In June of 2002, he scored his highest-profile win, an 8th-round knockout of Mike Tyson.
Herbie Hide: The hard punching Hide won the lightly regarded WBO heavyweight title from Michael Bentt with a seventh-round knockout in 1994. In his first title defense, Hide was knocked out by Riddick Bowe. Audley Harrison: Captured the super heavyweight gold medal at the 2000 Olympics in Sydney, Australia. As of November 2002, he was 8-0.

Danny Williams....

Matt Skelton....

Julius francis...

TFFP
07-10-2008, 07:25 PM
1. Lewis
2. Fitzsimmons
3. Cooper
4. Farr
5. Cockell

GazOC
07-10-2008, 07:29 PM
Gloved:

1) Lewis
2) Fitz
3) Cooper
4) Bruno
5) Farr

Honorable mention: Funso Banjo...;O)

I'm happy with the top two but would listen to arguments for Cooper, Bruno and Farr being swapped around. I think Farrs a little overated due to the Louis fight, he also lost to a lot of world class Yanks while Cooper dominated Europe but didn't have too many wins against top, prime Americans either.

TFFP
07-10-2008, 07:31 PM
Woodcock and Bugner are ones to think about. Don't rate Bruno highly personally, but can see why some have him.

GazOC
07-10-2008, 07:35 PM
Woodcock and Bugner are ones to think about. Don't rate Bruno highly personally, but can see why some have him.

I agree with Bugner, I'd maybe drop Farr for him.

JonOli
07-10-2008, 07:42 PM
The thing is with Bugner, if I remember rightly, is that he totally fell out of popularity with the British public when he made a comeback as an Aussie. Because of that people may underestimate his abilities.

Claypole
07-10-2008, 07:44 PM
I like the way that article describes Frank Bruno as having "above average power".
Maybe he would have been more successful if he had a proper dig on him, rather than just "above average power". In the same vein, I suppose Ali had "above average skill".

TFFP
07-10-2008, 07:46 PM
I think the inclusions of Harrison/Hide should be an indication as to the credibility of that article.

Reminds me of The Sun's 10 greatest British fighters of all-time.

Claypole
07-10-2008, 07:46 PM
The thing is with Bugner, if I remember rightly, is that he totally fell out of popularity with the British public when he made a comeback as an Aussie. Because of that people may underestimate his abilities.I think he fell out of favour in Britain when he got the decision over Cooper.

GazOC
07-10-2008, 07:47 PM
The thing is with Bugner, if I remember rightly, is that he totally fell out of popularity with the British public when he made a comeback as an Aussie. Because of that people may underestimate his abilities.

He was never that popular in the first place, he beat fans favourite Cooper in a close quarter of a point decision and often looked like his heart wasn't really in boxing despite having all the physical gifts.

Thinking about it I will swap Farr out for Bugner.

Lewis
Fitz
Cooper
Bruno
Bugner

JonOli
07-10-2008, 07:48 PM
I like the way that article describes Frank Bruno as having "above average power".
Maybe he would have been more successful if he had a proper dig on him, rather than just "above average power". In the same vein, I suppose Ali had "above average skill".

Yea, I see what your saying. I didn't post the article because I though it was particularly good; just to pull up some names for debate. When you think of British heavyweights not that many names automatically spring to mind (at least not with me). Please don't use that artical to make you decisions.

GazOC
07-10-2008, 07:53 PM
I didn't.....;O)

JonOli
07-10-2008, 07:53 PM
He was never that popular in the first place, he beat fans favourite Cooper in a close quarter of a point decision and often looked like his heart wasn't really in boxing despite having all the physical gifts.

Thinking about it I will swap Farr out for Bugner.

Lewis
Fitz
Cooper
Bruno
Bugner

The memories I have of Bugner were watching him when I was a small kid and him generally being disliked by those around. I have no idea what date that was, but it gets mixed up with my memories of the media furah of Bothams ashes. Whipping the Aussies etc...

GazOC
07-10-2008, 07:55 PM
That was (one of) Bugners comeback(s), his prime was when he was fighting out of Britain in the 70's.

JonOli
07-10-2008, 07:58 PM
I agree.

I'm just making the point that because he's not the medias favourite he may well be underrated as a boxer.

GazOC
07-10-2008, 08:00 PM
Ah, gotcha!!

Claypole
07-10-2008, 08:02 PM
Yea, I see what your saying. I didn't post the article because I though it was particularly good; just to pull up some names for debate. When you think of British heavyweights not that many names automatically spring to mind (at least not with me). Please don't use that artical to make you decisions.You're right about the amount of names, but they're an interesting lot though, British heavyweights.
I prefer our handcrafted lot to the factory made Americans; no two are the same (each one seems to have a unique flaw).

JonOli
07-10-2008, 08:06 PM
(each one seems to have a unique flaw).

You're right there. lol

Smith
07-10-2008, 08:06 PM
I think the inclusions of Harrison/Hide should be an indication as to the credibility of that article.

Reminds me of The Sun's 10 greatest British fighters of all-time.Elaborate:D:yep Im curious.

JonOli
07-10-2008, 08:08 PM
Make of what the article, what you will (thats not the debate). The artical has been posted just to open up names for debate.

GazOC
07-10-2008, 08:11 PM
Elaborate:D:yep Im curious.

Lets not eh? the "Welsh" thread is already in danger of going to shit....:roll:;)

JonOli
07-10-2008, 11:02 PM
Coopers version of the Knock down...

IzQZReUi3m4