IF.....IF Hatton beats PBF....

[TAM83]

Where would you have him in your P4P list?

Before everyone starts I'm not saying he will, just wondering where you guys would place him.

IMO he would be top 3 without doubt.

[McGrain]

2

[King Dan]

If Hatton - Floyd is a close win for Ricky, he goes to #1 pfp and Floyd goes to 2, 3 or 4....depends.

If Hatton wins easily, or by KO, he obviously is #1 and Floyd drops to 4 or 5 behind Hatton, Pac, Rafa + JMM Marquez and he gets lumped with Hop/Winky/Taylor/Calzaghe.

[TAM83]

If Hatton - Floyd is a close win for Ricky, he goes to #1 pfp and Floyd goes to 2, 3 or 4....depends.

If Hatton wins easily, or by KO, he obviously is #1 and Floyd drops to 4 or 5 behind Hatton, Pac, Rafa Marquez and he gets lumped with Hop/Winky/Taylor.

Seriously 4 or 5 after one defeat?

[El Bombasto]

Probably 2-3, Pac would most likely move to #1

[kirk]

i would put him at 1, he beat the p4p best in his prime....

1 - Hatton
2 - Mayweather
3 - Pac
4 - Winky (yes i know hopkins beat him... hopkins is also bigger and it was a close fight, winky still has the D with Taylor, W over mosley twice, and trinidad)
5 - Hopkins
6 - Rafa

[King Dan]

Seriously 4 or 5 after one defeat?

Floyd is not fighting Shane, Cotto, or Paul Willams, guys meant for the welterweight division or higher.

He's fighting Hatton who has shown he is meant for jr. welter after struggling with Collazo.

Mosley beta Collazo 9-3.....8-4 at worst.

[King Dan]

i would put him at 1, he beat the p4p best in his prime....

1 - Hatton
2 - Mayweather
3 - Pac
4 - Winky (yes i know hopkins beat him... hopkins is also bigger and it was a close fight, winky still has the D with Taylor, W over mosley twice, and trinidad)
5 - Hopkins
6 - Rafa

P4P this is a good list. I just would have Rafa marquez in that top 3 area, JM Marquez in that #5 or 6 slot.

[TAM83]

Floyd is not fighting Shane, Cotto, or Paul Willams, guys meant for the welterweight division or higher.

He's fighting Hatton who has shown he is meant for jr. welter after struggling with Collazo.

Mosley beta Collazo 9-3.....8-4 at worst.

Still though still seems a bit of a drop, he could catch him just like he caught Castillo. Nobody could take a bodyshot like that.

[BigEars]

Still though still seems a bit of a drop, he could catch him just like he caught Castillo. Nobody could take a bodyshot like that.

Ya but Tszyu disapeared from the pound for pound lists after his loss and Hopkins who was #1 dropped to at least 6 on most peoples lists after his loss(which no matter how we scored it all have to agree it was damn close) so a knockout loss could see Floyd drop well back .

[Dekkers]

Ya but Tszyu disapeared from the pound for pound lists after his loss and Hopkins who was #1 dropped to at least 6 on most peoples lists after his loss(which no matter how we scored it all have to agree it was damn close) so a knockout loss could see Floyd drop well back .
Tszyu was still top 10 after the loss on a lot of lists, he just dissapeared eventually due to unofficial retirement.

[gilad]

Floyd is not fighting Shane, Cotto, or Paul Willams, guys meant for the welterweight division or higher.

He's fighting Hatton who has shown he is meant for jr. welter after struggling with Collazo.

Mosley beta Collazo 9-3.....8-4 at worst.

Well, Collazo is better than what he showed against Mosely, I remind you he broke his hand on the second round and basically fought with one hand. Collazo is different fighter, Southpaw and a huge welterweight, unlike Floyd. I think Hatton-Floyd is actually a competetive matchup.

[brooklyn1550]

Anywhere from 1 to 3

[Alo2006]

Even though this is wishful thinking :yep either #1 or #2

[BobDigi5060]

I'd place him above Hopkins.

[rushman]

#2

[o_money]

I would put him at three provided pac beats MAB.

[Marnoff]

Wouldn't be able to argue with him anywhere in top 3.

[BigEars]

He'd be easily #1

Consider Mayweather got that mantle by default with Hopkins losing to Taylor, why shouldn't he be? He'd actually have earnt it

Lineal champ at the same time in 2 weight classes beating Tszyu, Castillo, Mayweather at 140-147. Only guy who would come close to that achievement would be PacMan

Or Rafael Marquez who is finally starting to get some of the respect he deserves on these pound for pound lists .

[Smazz20]

If he beats him at 140, i'd have him maybe 3rd behind Pacman and Hopkins. If he beats him at 147, i'd put him no.1.