Will Hatton be an ATG if...

[Napuis]

He beats Mayweather in November?


That would make three victories against three elites, with an unbeaten record to boot.

[Jose FM]

would become a strong candidate, but Gayweather overrated anyway.

[Danny Ocean]

gayweather.....how old are you thats what id expect out of a kid in the classroom

[Cookie]

I don't really go along with all this ATG stuff anymore. It's all so subjective. It's often even outright conjecture. Same with the P4P stuff.

If Hatton beats Mayweather then he'll be one of the most successful fighters of this decade. That much is for sure.

[El Bombasto]

no, but he'd be on his way

[doublesuited]

Yes.

[nervousxtian]

Wins over Judah, Maywether, and Zoo? He'd be HOF for sure, and history would probably be very nice when they look back at his career.

[Boinko]

Well, since PBF has decreed himself as the greatest P4P fighter who ever lived, then I guess Hatton would inherit that position.

[El Bombasto]

Wins over Judah, Maywether, and Zoo? He'd be HOF for sure, and history would probably be very nice when they look back at his career.

:huh

[SevenSamurai]

Of course, with his record and the fact he has beaten the p4p number mean he is a locked on ATG.

[AmazingHook]

Wins over Judah, Maywether, and Zoo? He'd be HOF for sure, and history would probably be very nice when they look back at his career.

Yeah, his win over Judah was just amazing.:lol: :lol:

[pipe wrenched]

I would think so if he continued with a couple more big wins to ice the cake.

[Scar]

All time great?, hell no. He needs more major wins.

[ApatheticLeader]

All time great?, hell no. He needs more major wins.What he said.

[RUSKULL]

I would say yes.

[RUSKULL]

Yeah, his win over Judah was just amazing.:lol: :lol:

:rofl

He meant well.

[john b]

He hasn't fought Judah and I have been watchingf him for the last 10 years.

[RUSKULL]

He hasn't fought Judah and I have been watchingf him for the last 10 years.

He made a mistake, I'm sure he meant Castillo.

[Marnoff]

Wins over Judah, Maywether, and Zoo? He'd be HOF for sure, and history would probably be very nice when they look back at his career.

The Judah win was easily the best of his career. It was almost as if it never happened, it was such a whitewash.

[Marnoff]

He'd definitely improve big time if he got this win, since Mayweather is unbeaten and whatnot, but I'd still look for him to get another big win.

[AmazingHook]

:rofl

He meant well.

:lol: ...but it sure is funny when people get so excited they start talking about fighters that never been in the the same ring.:rofl

[PATSYS]

He beats Mayweather in November?


That would make three victories against three elites, with an unbeaten record to boot.

Hell yes!

[ron u.k.]

in some eyes yes in others no.

[achillesthegreat]

Hatton is already arguably great and if he beat Floyd he wouldn't be great, he'd start to battle for legendary status with fighters like Leonard, Robinson and Armstrong.

At the moment he has a top 135 and 140 pounder on his record. In Floyd he could beat a top 130 pounder, plus be linear in his second weight class!!!

[Steve Fox]

He beats Mayweather in November?


That would make three victories against three elites, with an unbeaten record to boot.Lennox was an ATG, he was fighting quality opposition from early on in his career, cleaned up domestically and then internationally (pretty much). This modern breed of fighter seems to be trying to seek approval as an ATG as soon as they beat a well-known opponent.

[brooklyn1550]

Yes - he would have a 44-0 record with titles in 2 weight classes beating Mayweather, Tszyu, Castillo, Collazo, Phillips, and Tackie. He would be on the borderline, but I would consider him an all time great.

[warrior85]

yea

[Musashi]

Beating the #1 or 2 p4p fighter in the sport after beating Castillo and Tszyu? Yeah, that probably earns him ATG status. Or at least gets him close.

[BoppaZoo]

in terms of Greatness i think he will make the Hall of Fame.

and he probably only needs another 2 or 3 title wins to be assured a place in the HOF in my opinion.